[Marxism] The SWP, Respect and the united front.

Alan Bradley alanb1000 at yahoo.com
Sun Nov 4 18:34:57 MST 2007

From: mike pearn 
> That a new Mass Workers Party is needed in Britain
> I would agree but such a formation will not be
> until large numbers of workers move into struggle
> with the boss class. Whether that struggle begins in
> the economic or political fields is very secondary
> what matters is that revolutionaries are part of the
> process and can help move it towards the formation
> a class party.
> The formation of Respect in no way what so ever
> conforms to the above outline of how a new Mass
> Workers Party might arise. 

That should tell you something about the outline,
shouldn't it?

You've provided us with a textbook example of
schematicism. You set up an abstract model, and then
use it to reject a real world phenomenon that doesn't
conform to it.

There are plenty of dubious things about Respect, but
the fact that it doesn't conform to a model *that
exists only in someone's head* isn't one of them.

This is the same error Louis Proyect makes, too,
although the model is different.

Alan Bradley 

Do You Yahoo!?
Tired of spam?  Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around 

More information about the Marxism mailing list