[Marxism] XXX XXXX on the crisis in RESPECT

Einde O'Callaghan einde at gmx.de
Thu Nov 22 16:24:38 MST 2007

Louis Proyect schrieb:
> Nice to see you stepping into line. What would happen if you decided the 
> British SWP was wrong and said so publicly? Would they set up a 
> disciplinary committee and try you for indiscipline? And what would be 
> punishment? I don't think that expulsion would be adequate. You should 
> be forced to listen to the same Barry Manilow song for 24 hours straight.
I'm not a member of the British SWP, so I'm not stepping into any line - 
I'm just taking up what I feel are elements of bias in the approach to 
the dispute being adopted by some people. I would say however that the 
SWP is closer to Yoshi's position on some things than the current twist 
on the dispute in Britain would seem to allow.

Only a few weeks ago we (meaning those with a broadly similar approach 
to Islamist militants as the British SWP) were being denounced for our 
capitulation to communalism if not Islamo-fascism because we defend 
Muslims against racist persecution masquerading as secularism.

This aspect of our politics hasn't changed despite a particular 
constellation of disputes about vote fixing, packing meetings etc. in 

Einde O'Callaghan

More information about the Marxism mailing list