Santiago Colas scolas at
Thu Apr 27 19:31:51 MDT 1995


You need the book.  It contains, "Critique of Hegel's Doctrine of the
State," Letters from the _Franco-German Yearbooks_, "On the Jewish
Question," "A contribution to the Critique of Hegel's Philosophy of
Right.  Introduction,"  "Excerpts from James Mill's _Elements of
Political Economy_", EPM, and "Critical Notes on the Article 'The King of
Prussia and Social Reform.  By a Prussian'" plus in the Appendix the
Theses Concerning Feuerbach and the Preface to the 1859 Critique.  The
Hegel manuscript you were asking about is very worthwile indeed.
However, I can't speak for the translation's quality.



Santiago Colas					e-mail:	scolas at
Asst. Professor					phone:	(313) 763-4352
Latin American and Comparative Literature	fax:	(313) 764-8163
University of Michigan
Ann Arbor, MI  48109-1275

On Thu, 27 Apr 1995, Ralph Dumain wrote:

> Query: I am trying to decide whether to buy the Penguin edition of
> EARLY WORKS by Karl Marx, introduced by Lucio Colletti.  The one
> piece in there that interests me is the complete (I think) text of
> 'Critique of Hegel's Doctrine of the State'.  If this is the
> pivotal unpublished 1843 manuscript I have heard about under the
> name 'Critique of Hegel's Philosophy of Right'. then I definitely
> need this book, because I know of no other English translation of
> the whole thing in print.  (Note: I am NOT talking about the
> 'Critique of Hegel's Philosophy of Right -- Introduction" which
> was published by Marx in his newspaper and is often anthologized.)
> The introductory note for this piece (I saw it in a bookstore)
> mentions a couple of previous attempts at translation, of which I
> recall the one by Joseph O'Malley published circa 1970, which I
> can't find in used book stores.  So if the Penguin essay is (a)
> the same thing) (b) the complete and most up-to-date translation,
> then I need this book.  Along with Marx's essay on the Jewish
> question, this is the most important manuscript by Marx up to the
> 1844 Paris Manuscripts and the key critique of Hegel.  Anyone
> knowledgeable in this area?
>      --- from list marxism at ---

     --- from list marxism at ---


More information about the Marxism mailing list