the ultra-left on homosexuality?

sj at sj at
Mon Feb 6 20:52:14 MST 1995

I have a question to throw out into the crowd - I imagine that Alex Trotter
and Ralph Dumain, amongst others, may have something to say on the matter (I
hope so). Here goes:

Has anyone come across any ultra-left discussions of homosexuality from the
years *before* the late sixties? By ultra-left I mean the Dutch, German and
Italian 'Lefts' (e.g. Pannekoek, Mattick, Bordiga), as well as those groups
which emerged in the forties and fifties (the Johnson-Forest Tendency and its
various offshoots, Socialisme ou Barbarie, the situationists, those around
Munis). And I ask specifically about the period before 1968, since so many
people did start 'taking positions' on gay and lesbian identity after then.

My own suspicion - having been shaped by a lot of such perspectives in the
seventies - is that this wasn't an issue for any of the groups I've mentioned
apart perhaps for the *Correspondence*/*Facing Reality* and *News & Letters*
circles, and maybe not even for them... but I could be wrong. I also suspect
that the broader left libertarian milieu which such groups influenced would
have had rather more to say on the matter. Any thoughts or leads?

Steve Wright


More information about the Marxism mailing list