Quebec nationalism

Ryan Daum rdaum at
Sun Oct 22 16:02:53 MDT 1995

On Sun, 22 Oct 1995, Louis N Proyect wrote:

> Louis:
> Now, Alex, this is kind of work we've been hoping for from you from the 
> longest while. Keep it up!
> Ideas:    C+

I don't know, Louis.  Luxemburg was a great theorist, but her position of 
the national question is known to be rather ugly.  I.e. she supported the 
continued domination of Poland by Russia and attacked the socialist party 
there for supporting self-determination.  I'd give it a D.

As for supporting the Mohawk nation, et al.  Most certainly.  But you 
can't say that their rights are any more important than the rights of any 
other oppressed nation.  Are you going to form a "hierarchy of the 

== Ryan Daum -- rdaum at -- ===
--                 Defend Quebec's right to self-determination!             --

     --- from list marxism at ---

More information about the Marxism mailing list