Labour still the same as always?!!!??

Robert Malecki malecki at
Fri Aug 2 00:08:39 MDT 1996

Phillip writes;
>You don't get the point of the tranistional method.  Nowhere do you take
>into account the conciousness of the working class or its advanced layers.
>When the TP was written what were the questions being posed by history that
>the advanced workers were hinking about, discusing, debating etc:
>1) How do we defeat facism?
>2) How do we realize socialism?
>3) How do we overthorw capitalism?, etc, etc

No, you don,t get it! Try reading the very first page of the TP. It is
called "The Objective Prerequisites for a Socialist Revolution"..

IT ends up like this!

"All talk to the effect that historical conditions have not yet 'ripened'
for socialism is the product of ignorance or concious deception. The
objective prerequisites for the proletarian revolution have not only
'ripened'; they have begun to get some what rotten..."The historical crisis
of mankind is reduced to the crisis of the revolutionary leadership."

But for our fake Trotskyists Phillips arguements are in reality anti-marxist
and anti-Trotskyist. In fact a new slogan shall now be brought to the list.

"Trotskyist in name, Mensheviks in deed!"

That is the bottom line of the Militant group and the USec liquidationist
politics they stand for..


     --- from list marxism at ---

More information about the Marxism mailing list