Czech Communist Party Gains in Popularity

Owen Jones owen.jones at SPAMultramail.co.uk
Sun Aug 29 09:47:08 MDT 1999



 Mac, with all respect, if you are going to say such things you could at
least quote what I said. I don't know where that quote came from. This is in
fact what I said:

"Have the CCP capitulated to the market, and become little more than
reformist Social Democrats? Or are they a bunch of Stalinist ex-bureaucrats
seeking their power back?"

 What you quoted does indeed sound silly, but since I did not say it, in the
interests of fair debate, I hope you accept the correction. I stick to what
I said, even if you think that is sectarian. Would I be sectarian if I
denounced the Russian Communist Party, which is indeed led by opportunist
ex-Stalinist bureaucrats whose ranks include millionaire heads of casinos,
and who propagate nationalism of the most repugnant kind, splattered with a
liberal amount of anti-Semitism borrowed from Russia's dark past? I think I
have the right to be cautious before I go: "hip-hip-hooray, the Reds are
back!" Do you really want reformist Social Democrats in power - as many of
the ex-Stalinists who came back to power became - or a repeat of the
dictatorships that ruled half this continent in the post-war period? I
thought we had learnt our lessons from history.

 I'm sorry, I completely miss that analogy. Where was the connection?


>     That aside, I got a personal belly laugh at the question that "are they
> Social Democrats or Stalinist dictators?", too. It reminded me of a
> "Crossfire" on CNN that debated whether or not to "go in hard" or to use
> light bombs instead on Iraq, just before "Desert Fox". That, Owen, is the
> height of sectarianism.
> If you can't see that, please take another look.
>       And, by the way, glad you are back.
> Macdonald


--
Owen Jones

"Life is beautiful. Let the future generations cleanse it of all evil,
oppression, and violence and enjoy it to the full."

Leon Trotsky









More information about the Marxism mailing list