FW: Denounce US Biotech Appointment
jones118 at SPAMlineone.net
Fri Jun 2 17:03:20 MDT 2000
as long as we're talking Nader, here's this:
From: Biotech Activists [mailto:biotech_activists at iatp.org]
Sent: 02 June 2000 23:43
To: jones118 at lineone.net
Subject: Re: Denounce US Biotech Appointment
Biotech Activists (biotech_activists at iatp.org) Posted: 06/02/2000 By
phil at uwtc.washington.edu
We need to do more. There should be some organizing around this issue--to
delegitimate the body.
(BTW, on the EU side, Dan Leskin has played an important NGO role in the
Biosafety Protocol negotiations).
At 05:47 PM 6/1/00 -0500, you wrote:
>Biotech Activists (biotech_activists at iatp.org) Posted:
>06/01/2000 By mitchelcohen at mindspring.com
>MOTION: That the Greens (US & NY) and likely Green presidential candidate
>Ralph Nader denounce the White House's appointment of Carol Tucker Foreman
>to the Biotech Consultative Forum, and urge the US government to instead
>appoint the choice made by a number environmental groups -- Dr. Michael
>Hansen, of Consumer Union's Consumer Policy Institute -- to represent the
>interests of consumers on the Forum.
>(Submitted by Mitchel Cohen, Brooklyn Greens, Green Party of NY)
>Here's the Story:
>Ignoring the unanimous recommendation of consumer and agriculture groups
>concerned about biotechnology, the White House, with input from the US
>State Department, went ahead and appointed its own "consumer advocate" to
>the global Biotech Consultative Forum on May 31. While a number of groups
>had forwarded the name of Dr. Michael Hansen of Consumer Union's Consumer
>Policy Institute -- Dr. Hansen has testified before Congress and many other
>bodies exposing false claims made by the Monsanto Corporation pertaining to
>the company's manufacture of recombinant Bovine Growth Hormone and other
>products; the company refuses to debate him on the issues -- the White
>House appointed Carol Tucker Foreman of the very dubious "Consumer
>Federation of America" isntead.
>Carol Foreman represents consumer interests about as much as Indonesia
>represents the interests of E. Timor. Her last private sector project
>involved working as a lobbyist for Monsanto. She is currently is working on
>a grant from the Rockefeller Foundation, a heavy investor in biotechnology
>Rockefeller Foundation is represented by other Clinton/Gore appointees as
>well. With the exception of Becky Goldburg of the Environmental Defense
>Fund, there are no known critics of biotechnology appointed to the Board by
>the "environmental-friendly" Clinton/Gore administration. Corporate
>interests (including non-profit organizational mouthpieces for the biotech
>industry) are heavily weighted.
>Powerful Democratic lobbyist Carol Tucker Foreman last year left her
>lucrative lobbying firm and now heads up the food issues section, which
>includes Genetically Modified Organisms, for the Consumer Federation of
>America, a Greenwashing group which happily accepts food industry funding.
>She has since become a major player in international policy on genetically
>engineered food, with Rockefeller funding from Gordon Conway, apologist and
>promoter of Genetically Engineered crops.
>Foreman's many corporate clients have included Monsanto, Procter & Gamble,
>and other agribusiness and biotech companies, as well as the tobacco giant
>Philip Morris. PM is also the largest food corporation in the US.
>A search of Philip Morris documents on the web <www.pmdocs.com> reveals a
>1993 memo that lists the giant company's consultants for that year, with
>the dollar figure of $58,750.00 paid to Foreman's firm and the following
>description of her from document page 2046996749. (WRO probably refers to
>Philip Morris's Washington Regulatory Office):
>"Carol Foreman is one of the most respected consumer activists in
>town, formerly an Assistant Secretary of Agriculture. (Her brother is
>governor of Arkansas). She has been useful, mostly with New York public
>affairs programs, in providing strategy and advice on various interest
>groups. This retainer could be transferred to New York. It was originated
>in Washington since so many of the groups, ie National Women's Political
>(caucus) are here and coordination between WRO and PM/NY help to maximize
>our interests." [Thanks to Robert Lederman for digging this up.]
>The U.S. and the EU today agreed to establish a Consultative Forum to
>review and assess the benefits and risks of biotechnology and prepare a
>report on these issues for the December 2000 U.S.-EU Summit.
>The Forum will include individuals from outside government covering a broad
>perspectives, expertise, and interests -- people with backgrounds in labor,
>academia, and business, including scientists, ethicists, environmental
>interests, farmers, and consumers. They will look at factors such as the
>food security needs of developing countries, food safety, health and the
>environment. The forum will complement the existing bilateral dialogue,
>including the U.S.-EU transatlantic "dialogues" between sectors of
>civil society (business, labor, consumer, environmental).
>Lack of public confidence in the European food safety system has led to
>paralysis on approval of biotech foods. Genetically engineered crops are
>significantly undermining progress on food security in developing nations
>causing uncertainty in markets around the world and harming U.S. farm
>exports, as well as generating potential health and environmental risks.
>The EU's prevention of U.S. corn exports to Spain and Portugal costs U.S.
>producers around $200 million per year in lost corn sales (since 1998). Two
>new EU labeling regulations came into effect in April, but have not been
>implemented because of the lack of testing methodologies, certifying labs
>and inspection procedures.
>In October 1999, President Clinton and European Commission
>President Prodi agreed to take new steps to address differences
>over biotechnology, both through high-level government to
>government dialogue and with input from civil society. The leaders
>agreed to intensify U.S.-EU discussions on biotechnology in order to make
>progress on regulatory issues and to avoid and resolve trade problems.
>In December, the U.S. and the EU adopted a two-track approach. First, they
>established government-to-government talks through a special session of the
>U.S.-EU Senior Level Group. While these talks began early in 2000, they
>have yet to achieve progress on market access issues. With this week's
>announcement, the United States and EU have succeeded in launching the
>Consultative Forum to advise on these issues and have agreed to address
>practical steps to facilitate market access.
>EU Members of the EU-US Biotechnology Consultative Forum:
>Derek Burke, Prof., is former Professor of Microbiology at Warwick
>University and retired Chair of UK Advisory Committee on Novel Foods.
>Susan Davies, is Principal Policy Adviser of the Consumers' Association.
>Noëlle Lenoir, is Chair of the European Group on Ethics in science and new
>Technology, European Union.
>Dan Leskien, is advisor to Gesellschaft für Technische Zusammenarbeit on
>intellectual property rights and plant genetic resources in developing
>countries and permanent biotechnology advisor to Friends of the Earth.
>Måns Lönnroth, Ph.D., is Managing Director of MISTRA, the Swedish
>Foundation for Strategic Environmental Research and former State Secretary
>at the Swedish Ministry of the Environment.
>Ruud Lubbers, Prof., is Professor for Globalisation and Sustainable
>Development at the Catholic University Brabant (Tilburg University) and
>former Prime Minister of the Netherlands.
>Pedro Puigdoménech Rosell, Prof., is research Professor at the department
>of molecular genetics, Instituto de Biologia Molecular de Barcelona.
>Leonardo Santi, Prof., is President of the Advanced Biotechnology Center,
>Genoa, and Chairman of the National Committee for Biosafety and
>Biotechnology Presidency of Cabinet of Ministers Rome.
>Luis Vasconcelos e Souza, is President of the Portuguese Associations of
>Maize Producers and Vice-President of the European Association of Maize
>Eduard Veltkamp, Prof., is Senior Vice President, Business Research Foods,
>Unilever Research Laboratory Vlaardingen.
>U.S. Members of the US-EU Consultative Forum:
>Norman Borlaug, Ph.D., is currently Distinguished Professor of
>International Agriculture at Texas A&M University and won the Nobel Peace
>Prize in 1970 for his work on the "Green Revolution."
>Gordon Conway, Ph.D., is President of the Rockefeller Foundation and a
>world-renowned agricultural ecologist.
>Rebecca J. Goldburg, Ph.D., is Senior Scientist at Environmental Defense
>Cutberto Garza, M.D., Ph.D., is Vice Provost at Cornell University and
>Chair of the Food and Nutrition Board of the National Academies Institute
>Jennie Hunter-Cevera, Ph.D., is the President of the University of
>Maryland´s Biotechnology Institute.
>Terry Medley, J.D., is the Director of Regulatory and External Affairs for
>Christopher Roland Somerville, Ph.D., is the Director of The Carnegie
>Institute´s Department of Plant Biology at Stanford University.
>Carol Tucker Foreman is the Director of the Food Policy Institute of the
>Consumer Federation of America.
>Ryland Frederick Utlaut farms corn, soybeans and wheat near Grand Pass,
>Missouri and is the past President of the National Corn Growers
>LeRoy B. Walters, Ph.D., is the Director of the Kennedy Institute of Ethics
>at Georgetown University.
>How to Use this Mailing List
>You received this e-mail as a result of your registration on the
>biotech_activists mailing list.
>To unsubscribe, please send an email to listserv at iatp.org. In the body of
>the message type:
>For a list of other commands and list options, please send email to
>listserv at iatp.org.
>In the body of the message type:
>Please direct content questions about this list to: mritchie at iatp.org
>Please direct technical questions about this service to: support at iatp.org
Philip L. Bereano
Department of Technical Communication
College of Engineering
University of Washington
Seattle, Wash. 98195
phone: (206) 543-9037
fax: (206) 543-8858
The problem with the gene pool is that there is no lifeguard.
"Americans recognize fewer than 10 plant species, but over 1,000 corporate
How to Use this Mailing List
You received this e-mail as a result of your registration on the
biotech_activists mailing list.
To unsubscribe, please send an email to listserv at iatp.org. In the body of
the message type:
For a list of other commands and list options, please send email to
listserv at iatp.org.
In the body of the message type:
Please direct content questions about this list to: mritchie at iatp.org
Please direct technical questions about this service to: support at iatp.org
More information about the Marxism