Re.: Sharon, spearhead of the terrorist state

Chris Brady chris_brady at
Sun Oct 15 01:25:47 MDT 2000

I think the notion of making a distinction between "Jew" and "Zionist"
is important, especially in the USA.  Understandably it is not so
urgent in the midst of organizing formations and actions Palestine.
But the impact (=word carefully chosen) of the USA on Palestine is not
insignificant. The propaganda of the Zionist cause has been amazingly
effective in the imperialist states.

Ordinary working class people have very little education about what
goes on in the world.  For example, few Americans know how the Zionist
state excludes Palestinian Christians, that is Armenians, Maronites,
Eastern and Greek Orthodox, etc., as well as all Palestinian Muslims,
i.e., Sunni and Shi'a.  You might think that the right-wing
fundamentalist Christians who have such influence in US politics
would show some solidarity with their brethren, but the Christians
in the Mid East do not fill the collection plates in the Mid West.
As we used to say back in my days as a carpenter and bartender,
"Money talks, and bullshit walks."

Speaking of which, I can remember myself being remonstrasted as a
young man in the Seventies on Columbus Avenue in the little bar
where I worked.  I had made a remark, only in passing, for the purpose
of some lame joke as I recall, about Israel being a victim of Arab
intransigence. Most humor of the sort is looslely based on common
understandings, but that is another topic.  The young black guy I was
bantering with was a regular, a guy my age.  Usually a softspoken
fellow, with a good sense of humor, he stopped me short and told me
I knew nothing about the situation.

I was taken aback. A verbal shot like "You don't know what you're
talking about" in such an environment can be taken as a challenge,
but he patiently explained that Israel was the last European colony
of the Twentieth Century.  He told me about a people who had been
violently expelled from their own homes and asked me if I would accept
such circumstances.  Think of your mother, your family, he advised.
Would you be true to them?  Would you be "intransigent?"

This had quite an effect on my thinking.  I remember it to this day.
It helped direct a new interpretation of world events for me, and
to a critical appraisal of the US media, and propaganda.
Do not think the propaganda war is pointless.
But it also made me realize, as have other incidents before and since,
of the importance of asserting the facts.  The fact is not all Jews
are Zionists.  From what I have learned of the twentieth century in
Palestine, I can conceive of no other solution but the creation of a
secular socialist state there.  Eventually the majority of the people
there will have to accept and welcome that idea to make it a fact.
That includes the Jews.

Show that there is a difference between Jews and Zionists.
Learn the lessons of the conquerors: divide and rule.
Allies unite.
Again it comes down to the essential unification spoken
of by Karl and Fred at the end of the Communist Manifesto.
The working class Jews of Israel have to realize that their
families are put in harm's way by a capitalist state that exists
for and by war.  They have to see that their allies for peace
are the very people that the Zionist state vilifies as their
eternal enemies: the working class of Palestine.

But I suspect the leaders of the Palestinians are just as committed
as the leaders of the Zionists and of the USA against socialism as
it is against their better interests.

Chris Brady

More information about the Marxism mailing list