City bans scarves during summit, fearing protests

Macdonald Stainsby mstainsby at
Thu Mar 1 20:36:13 MST 2001

City bans scarves during summit, fearing protests
Summit of the americas
Feb. 26, 2001

Anne Marie Owens and Heather Sokoloff
National Post

Ian Lindsay, The Vancouver Sun

Protesters at talks of the World Trade Organization in Seattle covered
their faces. Quebec City and the suburb of Saint-Foy have passed an
anti-scarf by-law as a security measure for the Summit of the Americas in

People in the Quebec City suburb of Saint-Foy could soon risk being
arrested for wearing scarves or covering up their faces.

A new by-law, which was adopted as part of security preparations for the
upcoming Summit of the Americas conference in Quebec City, is one example
of precautions being taken to squelch the activities of anti-globalization
activists and protesters who typically target these types of international

In addition to the scarf by-law, authorities plan to install a three-metre
high metal fence around several square kilometres of Quebec City and allow
only those with passes inside the perimeter. The area will be enforced by
3,000 to 5,000 police, RCMP and riot squads from across the country, and
police are freeing up 500 spots in the Quebec City prison to make room for
arrested protesters.

The by-law adopted by Saint-Foy councillors, which will be enforced during
the weeks leading up to and including the April summit, permits police to
immediately arrest someone in a crowd if even part of their face is

A similar by-law is already in place in Quebec City.

If arrested, the burden of proof rests with the accused for providing a
valid excuse for covering up their faces, according to the by-law.

"I think the Quebec authorities responsible for this owe the public a
pretty full example as to why they think an extraordinary measure like
that is needed," said Alan Borovoy, general counsel of the Canadian Civil
Liberties Association. "I can imagine all sorts of perfectly logical
reasons why someone would have part of their face covered."

Mr. Borovoy says his organization grew concerned after seeing how various
cities have fought the inevitable protests and hearing how Quebec
authorities were ramping up for this particular session.

He says authorities "should not arrest, detain, search, seize or use force
beyond what is necessary to uphold the law."

The association has criticized the focus of the security tactics and urged
the federal Solicitor-General and Quebec's Public Security Minister
against using a heavy-handed and one-sided approach.

"Just as it is important to ensure the security of the summit, it is no
less important to protect the viability of the protests," said Mr.

"It is beginning to appear that the protesters will be quarantined miles
from the centre of conference activity ... The further away the protesters
are, the less viable their protest will be."

The April 20-22 meeting will bring together the leaders of 34 countries,
including Jean Chritien, the Prime Minister, and George W. Bush, the U.S.
President, to discuss creating a free-trade zone covering all of North and
South America.

These gatherings have become a touchstone for anti-globalization
activists, particularly in the wake of the violence that erupted at the
1999 World Trade Organization talks in Seattle.

Macdonald Stainsby
Rad-Green List: Radical anti-capitalist environmental discussion.
Leninist-International: Building bridges in the tradition of V.I. Lenin.
In the contradiction lies the hope.
                                     --Bertholt Brecht

More information about the Marxism mailing list