A suggestion to Eduardo Enriquez

Eduardo Enriquez eldiablito666 at yahoo.com
Sun Sep 16 22:56:44 MDT 2001


--- Louis Proyect <lnp3 at panix.com> wrote:
> On Sat, 15 Sep 2001 23:19:45 -0700 (PDT), Eduardo
> Enriquez wrote:
>
> >let's read what the encarta encyclopedia tells
> >us about MR. Peron which is something most books
> >will also tell us about Peron and indeed latin
> >american leftists as well as leftists from other
> >parts.
>
> Mr. Enriquez, I have not really paid much attention
> to you because of
> the discussions taking place on the World Trade
> Center events. But to
> be as succinct as possible, this list was not
> created to be a
> repository for Micro$oft's Encarta Encyclopedia. If
> we need
> information on Peron, we expect it to come from
> sources on the left
> and not from a criminal enterprise run by top mafia
> man Bill Gates.

I USED mr. GATES ENCYCLOPEDIA IN ORDER TO SHOW HOW
EVEN IN SOMETHING LIKE THAT ONE WILL FIND THE LISTING
OF FACTS LIKE mR. PERON'S ADMIRATION FOR BENITO
MUSSOLINI AND HIS DEPURATION OF LEFT WING INFLUENCE
FROM ARGENTINIAN TRADE UNIONS.
WHY I DID THIS. WELL BECAUSE I COULD'T UNDERSTAND HOW
SOMEONE ON A LIST LIKE THIS COULD HAVE SYMPHATHY FOR
SOMEONE LIKE JUAN PERON.
>
> Furthermore, this is a list that is very much in the
> Leninist
> tradition. That is why there are images of Castro
> and Guevara on the
> Subscription page.

WELL, NOT PARTICULARLY TOO CRAZY FOR THEM PERSONALLY.
PERHAPS A LITTLE SYMPHATHY FOR mR. GUEVARA YET I'M NOT
TOO EXCESSIVELY MOVED BY SUCH SUICIDAL IDIOCY WHICH
HAS NOT THE OPREESSED BEHIND HIM AND THUS WHICH IS
BOUND TO FAILURE. MMR. GUEVARA IS TOO FAR IN MY
PERSONAL SYMPHATHY  FROM OTHER MARTYRS LIKE ROSA
LUXEMBOURG OR MARTIN LUTHER KING.

I do not try to enforce strict
> ideological
> discipline on the list and we have co-existed with
> at least one
> person who rejects that tradition, but it appears to
> me that you are
> on a collision course with the list.
>
> There are other Marxism and leftist lists on the
> Internet with which
> you would be more compatible I'm sure, starting
> with:
>
> http://groups.yahoo.com/group/marxist
>
> If you remain here, it will be necessary for you to
> keep your
> anti-Communism to yourself.

I REJECT THE MONOPOLIZATION OF THE LENINIST STALINIST
CAMP OF THE WORD "COMMUNISM". LETS FIRST START THAT TO
CALL "COMMUNISM TO SOMETHING LIKE CUBA IS ONLY AN
INSULT TO THE WORD "COMMUNISM" IN MY OPINION SINCE
WHAT REALLY HAS POWER OVER THE MODES OF PRODUCTION
THERE ARE NOT THE WORKERS THEMSELVES BUT A FEW PARTY
BOSES AND MR. CASTRO. TO CALL WHAT EXISTED IN TITO'S
YUGOSLAVIA OR IN THE SO CALLED SPANISH REVOLUTION OF
THE MID 30'S "COMMUNISM" OR "SOCIALISM" IS TO ME MORE
APPROPIATE. IF YOU DIDNT KNOW THERE HAVE MANY
COMMUNIST EXPERIMENTS IN COMMUNISM BEFORE THE SOVIET
UNION LIKE SAY MANY EXISTING IN NORTH AMERICA BEFORE
THE EUROPEANS CAME OR THE EUROPEAN HERETIC CATHOLIC
ANABAPTIST SECT AND OF COURSE OTHER POLITICAL SECTORS
ON THE LEFT USE THE WORD "COMMUNISM" SUCH AS THE
FOLLOWERS OF PETER KROPOTKIN'S "ANARCHIST COMMUNISM".

But why put up with such
> a constraint?
> Either take a look at the list above at Yahoo, or
> contact me
> privately. In my 7 years on the Internet, I have
> become very familiar
> with the locations of email lists that share your
> distaste for Cuba,
> etc.
>


I DONT HAVE A DISTASTE FOR "CUBA". WHAT I HAVE IS A
DISTASTE FOR ITS DICTATORS AND THE SUPPRESSION OF
BASIC CIVIC LIBERTIES AND OF HUMAN RIGHTS THAT THEY
ENNACT ON THE CUBAN PEOPLE
>
> --
> Louis Proyect, lnp3 at panix.com on 09/16/2001
>
> Marxism list: http://www.marxmail.org
>
>
ALLRIGHT THATS VERY NICE THANK YOU. I HAVE ALSO
NOTICED THIS MIGHT NOT BE MY PLACE.

__________________________________________________
Terrorist Attacks on U.S. - How can you help?
Donate cash, emergency relief information
http://dailynews.yahoo.com/fc/US/Emergency_Information/
=======
PLEASE clip all extraneous text before replying to a message



More information about the Marxism mailing list