Make an argument, please...(re: WSF)

Derrick O'Keefe sankara83 at
Sat Feb 2 11:37:06 MST 2002

Patrick Bond,
>Comrade, like Chuck0 on Doug Henwood's list dissing Porto Alegre for being
>the preserve of yuppie NGOs, I don't think you should trash it so

I wasn't trashing the WSF conclusively.  I simply forwarded an open letter
from Brazilian trade unionists that raises several points.  Are you refuting
their arguments that "civil society" is a disorienting concept or that the
participatory budget of Porto Alegre is far, far from a panacea?  The fact
that the World Bank president wasn't allowed to speak isn't irrefutable
evidence of correct politics.  Please, make an argument with your next

Derrick O'Keefe

Chat with friends online, try MSN Messenger:

PLEASE clip all extraneous text before replying to a message.

More information about the Marxism mailing list