More on Taking Apart Hardt

Patrick Bond pbond at
Sun Feb 23 02:21:38 MST 2003

----- Original Message -----
From: "Derek S." <derektheredrebel at>
> If you're worried about turning off newly radicalized
> students who have been seduced by Hardt, it's not as
> if I (or Juniad or Louis, from what I know of them) am
> going to go up to one and start bashing him in the
> exact rough (but accurate) way Junaid did. I'd like to
> think we'd try to explain our differences in a mature
> manner and try to convince them by appealing to their
> sense of judgement.

Yeah, you're right, I should have put this in context...

> This is a list that is overwhelmingly composed of
> marxists who are not so green as a newly revved-up
> student radical though, and know about the differences
> on the left already and can dicuss them frankily. If
> someone like Junaid wants to vent his frustration to a
> community of cothinkers on this list, I'm all for it,
> as long as he still makes a coherent argument and
> doesn't attack any listmembers personally.

PLEASE clip all extraneous text before replying to a message.

More information about the Marxism mailing list