The Lords of Vengeance

Ralph Johansen michele at
Mon Mar 24 03:57:30 MST 2003

     The Lords of Vengeance
     By William Rivers Pitt
     t r u t h o u t | Perspective

     Monday 24 March 2003

     We have become, with a sudden jolt, a divided nation in this time of
war.  Demands that Americans leave aside protests, accusations and anger in
order to support our military work in Iraq have gone unheeded by great
segments of the population.  Millions of people have poured into the streets
of virtually every city in the country to demand that the bombing be
stopped, and that the troops be brought safely home.  Those protests have
been met by equally enraged citizens who see these protests as an aid to
terrorists and an act of treason.  Americans scream obscenities at Americans
across lines created by armored police.

     This will only get worse, as both groups are hardened in their opinions
and beliefs.  In the final analysis, questions of who is right and who is
wrong fall by the wayside, as both sides stand secure in their rectitude.
In such a polarized situation, right and wrong will be determined between
these groups when one side quits.

     Caught in the middle is a group far larger than the combined mass of
the citizens described above.  This group may be unsure, may fall to one
side or the other on a daily basis, but essentially support the war.  It is
to this group in particular that I address my words.

     I understand why you support this engagement.  At bottom, you do so
because you are loyal.  The President has said it must be so, and so it must
be so.  The loyalty of this nation's citizenry is now and has always been
our greatest strength.  Many of you who support the war are veterans of
other conflicts, and so your support is based upon a desire to stand with
the troops now in harm's way.  This is more than honorable.

     Many of you believe this must happen because you have been told, time
and again, that Saddam Hussein possesses an awesome arsenal of mass
destruction weapons that he will gladly give to terrorists for use against
us.  Your belief that this is so stems from your loyalty – the President has
told you it is true, and so it must be true.  It is fearful indeed to
consider weapons like this in the hands of terrorists.

     You must know, however, that no proof of either prohibited weapons
possession or connections to terrorism on the part of Saddam Hussein has
been offered by the administration.  They have made many accusations, and
offered chunks of evidence, but over the last weeks and months each and
every bit of evidence put forth has been debunked.  Sometimes, the press has
proven them wrong, sometimes the weapons inspectors in Iraq proved them
wrong, and sometimes our own intelligence services proved them wrong.  No
proof offered by the Bush administration has stood up.  None.

     Likewise, many of you support this war because of the deplorable
suffering Saddam Hussein has inflicted upon his own people.  There is no
denying the barbarous nature of this dictator, and no one worth a damn would
ever lift a finger to defend his actions.  You have been told that the Iraqi
people will be freed by this conflict, that democracy is coming to that
tired and torn nation.  For many of you, this is more than enough reason to
support this action.

     Unfortunately, it is all but certain that the Iraqi people will see
neither freedom nor democracy because of the cultural divisions within that
nation.  Iraq is divided into three groups: Shia, Sunni and Kurd.  The Shia
make up over 60% of the Iraqi population, and are ideologically and
theocratically aligned with the hard-liners who rule Iran.  Should we bring
western-style majority-rules democracy to Iraq, we would be setting the
stage for a debilitating alliance between Iran and Iraq.  The Kurds will
never be allowed to rule Iraq or anything else; we have already promised
Turkey this.  Only the Sunnis remain as the viable future leaders of Iraq.
Saddam Hussein is a Sunni, and the tribal politics of the Iraqi Sunni
guarantee that whoever replaces Hussein will be as bad as he was to the
other Iraqi groups, or worse.

     I fear that too many of you support this war because you have relied
upon our mainstream television news media for information about this whole
issue.  It is telling indeed that, in an age where news comes in 24 hour
chunks, where viewers have a galaxy of channels to watch and become
informed, some 40% of Americans believe that Saddam Hussein was directly
responsible for and involved in the attacks of September 11.  This simply
isn't true; virtually every non-partisan and objective source considered
credible in America dismisses said connection out of hand.  The fact that
this glaring misconception is held by such a large group of Americans shines
a nauseating light upon the level of journalism being practiced by those who
come on our televisions to provide us with the facts.  It is also
worthwhile, and disappointing, to note that the Bush administration has done
little, if anything, to disabuse Americans of this very incorrect

     At the end of the day, though, I think I know the true reason why you
support this war.  You still see September 11th when you close your eyes.
You still fear blue skies and airplanes.  You tremble when your subway dives
down into a tunnel, you grip the wheel tighter when you drive across a
bridge, and your stomach sinks when you know that, again tomorrow, you must
face a day of work in a high-rise office building.  You, a mighty American,
citizen of the greatest nation that has ever existed, have been made to fear
on your own soil.

     Somehow, somewhere, someone has to pay for that.  Afghanistan was not
enough, though our forces destroyed at least as many civilians in driving
out the Taliban as were lost in New York and Washington and Pennsylvania.
It does not satisfy, because you know that in some place under the stars
right now, Osama bin Laden is walking around alive and free.

     George W. Bush, Donald Rumsfeld and the generals and soldiers who now
wage war in Iraq are your lords of vengeance.  They bring the hard fist of
retaliation down upon a nation we have despised for over a decade now.  You
speak of fearing chemical weapons, you speak of standing with the troops,
you speak of bringing freedom and democracy to the Iraqi people, but when
all is said and done you watch the terrible blooming of fires and explosions
in Baghdad and a voice whispers within you, "There.  Payback.  Finally,

I cannot, and would not, judge you for this, for I feel the same way about
9/11.  Few Americans, even after the time that has passed, can contemplate
that day without feeling a desire to see someone bleed for it.

     Yet even that dark and ancient reason must bend to the consequences.
Seventy two hours of war on Iraq have passed, and in that short time a
number of incredibly bad things have happened.  We shot down a British plane
with one of our Patriot missiles, killing the crew.  An as-yet uncounted
number of American Marines have been killed and wounded in clashes near
Nasiriya, and others have died in a helicopter crash.  Twelve Americans have
been captured by Iraqi forces and are being held in an undisclosed location.
Images of their faces were broadcast on the Al Jazeera network, and it was
clear that many were wounded.

     Several American missiles have struck targets in Iran, including a
government building that housed the Iranian Oil Ministry.  Iran has reacted
to this with anger, and if they decide to roll tanks and engage in this
fight, our forces will be in grave trouble.  To the north, Turkish forces
have poured across the border into Iraq.  Turkey has for years coveted the
oil fields around Mosul and Kirkuk, and has likewise wished to crush for all
time the Kurds and their hopes for an independent state.

     A soldier with the 101st Airborne apparently went mad and attempted to
assassinate his brigade commanders in a grenade attack that killed one
person and wounded a dozen others.  The Vietnam war gave us a term for such
an atrocity: "Fragging."  The soldier in question has been detained, and
there is an investigation underway, but the blow to morale among Airborne
troops is incalculable.

     Baghdad, Basra and several other cities have been bombed repeatedly,
setting ablaze neighborhoods and killing scores of civilians.  Perhaps most
frightening is the fact that the Marines who fought in Nasiriya came under
fire from Iraqis wearing civilian clothes.  It has been posited that these
were Iraqi troops dressed as common civilians, and this may be true.  It
could also be true that the Iraqi people are not greeting American forces
with the joy we were expecting.  The fact remains, however, that from this
point on every civilian in Iraq will be considered hostile.  This was the
darkest aspect of the Vietnam war, when troops were unable to tell friend
from foe.  The confusion led not only to great strain among our soldiers,
but to terrible acts of violence perpetrated against innocent

     Basra has not fallen.  Umm Qasr has not fallen.  Nasiriya has not
fallen.  Resistance has grown exponentially, and our casualties mount.
Looming in the distance is Baghdad and urban warfare, which may begin as
soon as Tuesday.  The death toll among our fighting men and women will rise
in horrible fashion if we become engaged in a street-to-street fight for the
capitol city.  After that comes Tikrit, family seat and final stronghold for
Saddam Hussein and his supporters, and another potential urban clash.

     This wretched list of dreadful news will grow longer with each passing
day.  Our brave men and women in the armed services will continue to die,
along with untold numbers of innocent civilians.  There is no end in sight;
Bush administration officials who have organized this conflict have stated
clearly, in documents stretching as far back as 1997, that Iraq is only the
beginning of a wider war to reorganize that entire region.  You may have
noticed that there has been no exit strategy offered by the administration
for this conflict.  There isn't one, because we have no intention of

     The polarization and anger within this country will strain us to the
breaking point.  Across the world, anger at America's actions in this
conflict will rise and rise and rise until we are, truly and at last,
completely despised and completely alone.

     Never forget, also, that there are other lords of vengeance in the
world.  They have proven, vividly, that they can strike us to the heart at
the time and place of their choosing.  None of them are in Iraq, but all of
them will seek our blood in payment for the Muslim civilians who die in this
war.  Should this conflict inspire them to act, many Americans will die
within our borders.  The resulting constitutional lockdown will end,
forever, the ideas that formed the basis for this country.  The war should
be taken to these groups, in their secret places and their bank accounts,
and not past them to Baghdad.

     The choice is yours to make.  Vengeance comes from the stomach, and
hope from the soul.  In this matter, use your eyes and your mind to decide
where you stand.  Many terrible things will resolve themselves in a far
better fashion if you can find it within yourself to say six simple words.

     Stop the bombing.  Stop the war.

PLEASE clip all extraneous text before replying to a message.

More information about the Marxism mailing list