[Marxism] Fwd: Books on the Spanish Civil War

Jon Flanders jonathan.flanders at verizon.net
Sun Apr 18 17:05:44 MDT 2004

How about "The Spanish Civil War" by Hugh Thomas? I believe that this
book is considered the standard text.

Or Homage to Catalonia by Orwell?

Jon Flanders

Book Review: The Spanish Civil War by Hugh Thomas

by Blas Pedro Uberuaga

June 28, 2003

Read: December 2000 to January 2001.

In his very interesting book, Hugh Thomas starts with the events that
lead up to the Spanish Civil War and then follows on with the details of
the war itself. From a Basque point of view, any understanding of the
political situation today requires a familiarity with the Spanish Civil
War, and this book delivers.

The Basques are often labelled as communists for their role in the war.
It is true that they were on the side of the Republic, which was the
legitimate government in Spain before the war started, and the Republic
contained many influencial communists. But, the Basques were in the war
to protect both their hopes of autonomy as well as the liberty they
cherished, which the Nationalists (Franco and the Carlists) wanted to

The Republic was forced to go to the Soviets for aid, both for supplies
and expertise, as the democracies of Europe and the United States
wouldn't supply any. The reason was because of the Non-Intervention
Committee, a committee set up by the British, French, Soviets, Germans,
and Italians, amoung others, to prevent any of the powers of Europe from
intervening in the war. However, the Italians and Germans still supplied
Franco with supplies and personel. The British and French were too
fearful of the war escalating to a larger, European war. Thus, the
Italians and Germans were able to help the Nationalists without the
Republic receiving much aid. The Soviets were able to supply some aid,
though it wasn't enough to prevent the Republic from losing.

The Basques were conquered by a lack of supplies and also because of
treachery. At least, at the end, Bilbo was conquered, in no small part,
because of the treachery of a Basque officer who defected and revealed
details about the defences of the city. The Basques were always
different from the rest of the Republic, in that one group, the
Basque-Nationalists, had control of the government and the army. This
wasn't true in the other parts, where the Communists and Anarchists were
generally in control.

The Republic was handicapped by more than just supplies, but also
because of constant squables between the Communists, Socialists and
Anarchists. The Anarchists were actually in control in Barcelona,
something Thomas points out was the first time Anarchists had been in
control of a major city anywhere in the world. They had several changes
of government as they tried to be accomodating to the more powerful
groups not represented in the current government. The lack of stability
and the lack of supplies were the reasons that the Republic lost to the
Nationalists. The Nationalists were able to get supplies at just the
critical moments and the Republic was not.

To a modern reader, it seems like the war was fought a bit ineptly on
both sides. That is, neither had any kind of superiority in terms of
military capability and both made many big mistakes.

Both sides committed many atrocities. The Anarchists killed many
religious people or Fascist sympathizers wherever they gained control.
The Fascists did the same to Communists and also attacked many religious
people in the Basque Country since they sided with the Basques.

The war was an experimental test-ground for the Italians and, even more,
the Germans, who tested combat strategies as well as ways to employ air
force and tank formations, in preparation for future wars. The future
Allies of World War II learned the wrong lessons, especially in terms of
how to use tanks, which caused many failures in WWII.

This book is a typical history book, describing a lot of details, but it
also has some remarks by the author that both lightened the tone as well
as giving his personal feelings about some of the events.

The Spanish Civil war defined Spanish history from then on. It also lead
to some of the happenings of WWII, as the Germans and Italians were able
to go unchecked in their response to the war and this undoubtedly gave
them confidence that they could achieve whatever they wanted without
reprecussions from France and England. This book is a fitting testament
to this monumentous event.  

More information about the Marxism mailing list