[Marxism] Re: The hijab controversy

Richard Fidler rfidler at cyberus.ca
Mon Feb 16 07:58:38 MST 2004


Paul Flewers writes>>Socialists should combine the defence of the right of a Muslim woman
to wear a veil (or a Jewish man to wear a yarmulke, or a Christian to wear a cross), if
that person wishes, with a firm commitment to a secular society, that religion is a
private matter, and that education is secular. This involves the abolition of religious
schools and their resources being brought into the state educational system.<<

To which José Pérez replies, with his usual hyperbole:

>>This is an utterly undemocratic and *outrageously* anti Marxist position, drawn from
exactly the same French bourgeois anticlericalist traditions that are being used to
justify the ban on the veil. <<

Comment:
Excuse me? The quotation from Marx's critique of the Gotha Program that José cites says,
inter alia:

"Government and church should rather be equally excluded from any influence on the
school."

How does that differ from what Paul Flewers said, and said very well, IMHO?

RF


---
Outgoing mail is certified Virus Free.
Checked by AVG anti-virus system (http://www.grisoft.com).
Version: 6.0.587 / Virus Database: 371 - Release Date: 12-02-2004





More information about the Marxism mailing list