[Marxism] Re: Not a dime's worth of difference
andrew c pollack
andypollack at juno.com
Wed Jul 21 21:06:23 MDT 2004
I wanted to make sure folks didn't miss the Daley-Bloomberg comparison in
the second article posted under this subject line -- in which Bloomberg
comes off worse than Daley! Hearing Bloomberg's repeated disdain for
protesters, the press, his political opponents -- every time I hear him
say to myself "that's just how a corporate executive acts at work, where
there's no right of free speech." And I think Cohen draws that out nicely
with the Daley comparison.
This is important for longer-term purposes too, as we remember how much
worse US authoritarianism can become -- worse than any tyranny the planet
has yet seen -- when corporate interests are some day challenged in a
On Wed, 21 Jul 2004 10:44:39 -0400 Louis Proyect <lnp3 at panix.com> writes:
> NY Times, July 19, 2004
> EDITORIAL OBSERVER
> Pop Quiz: What Do New York 2004 and Chicago 1968 Have in Common?
> By ADAM COHEN
> If trouble breaks out between police and demonstrators at next
> Republican convention, the media will be quick to draw comparisons
> the 1968 Democratic convention in Chicago. Mayor Richard J. Daley's
> rampaging police who injured hundreds of unarmed protesters and
> bystanders provided one of the great cautionary tales in American
> politics, and one that is already on the mind of the Bloomberg
> administration. In a recent interview, the mayor's communications
> director rushed to say, before I could even raise the subject, that
> boss was no Mayor Daley, and that this was not Chicago in 1968.
> As the co-author of a lengthy Daley biography, "American Pharaoh:
> Richard J. Daley: His Battle for Chicago and the Nation," I can
> that the two mayors are not much alike. Mayor Michael Bloomberg, who
> made $5 billion at the intersection of finance and technology, is a
> world away from Mayor Daley the father of Chicago's current mayor
> who plodded his way up an old-line Democratic machine, and lived his
> whole life in the working-class neighborhood of Bridgeport. And
> the probity and professionalism Mayor Bloomberg has shown in office,
> Chicago-style debacle seems unlikely here. Still, these two men seem
> have a remarkably similar distaste for demonstrators and for
> similar reasons.
> Mayor Daley's dislike of protests was largely rooted in his view of
> politics. The Chicago machine was built on the principle that the
> way to
> have a voice in government was to pay one's dues at the precinct
> by turning out the vote. Mayor Daley shared the machine's
> pragmatic values, and was offended by anyone who made demands on
> officials without helping to elect them.
> When the Rev. Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. brought the civil rights
> movement to Chicago in 1966, his idealistic words about equal
> opportunity and fair housing were lost on the mayor. Mayor Daley
> not believe that Dr. King expected to dictate policy to city hall
> he did not control a single precinct captain.
> Mayor Daley viewed the 1968 protesters in much the same way. When I
> started work on the Daley book, I shared the common misconception
> Mayor Daley hated antiwar protesters because he supported the
> War. But I soon learned that he opposed the war, and had quietly
> to persuade President Lyndon Johnson to withdraw the troops. The
> objection was in a way procedural. If the demonstrators wanted to
> the war, it seemed to him, they should have done the hard political
> to be where he was that week: inside the convention hall.
> Mayor Bloomberg's roots lie in a social organization that's very
> different from the clubhouse, but equally intolerant of spontaneous
> outbursts. Until he ran for mayor he had spent his life in the
> world, where as in a political machine people pursue a common
> by working through the system. Employees who try to harangue leaders
> into changing corporate policy are not engaging in free speech. They
> being insubordinate.
> In his handling of demonstrators, Mayor Bloomberg has acted like a
> corporate leader dealing with unruly subordinates. His police have
> confined them in metal "pens," and treated them with a roughness
> makes protesting the government a grueling experience. The New York
> Civil Liberties Union is suing on behalf of a diabetic,
> New Yorker who says she was kept in a pen at a protest last year
> a medical need to leave.
> In the negotiations over next month's anti-Republican protests, the
> initially tried to force the 250,000 demonstrators who want to
> gather in
> Central Park into Queens. Its final offer is a site on the West Side
> Highway, an uncomfortable, out-of-the-way, narrow venue that will
> it impossible to gather as a group to hear speakers. Mayor Bloomberg
> delegated the negotiations to the police, stepping in only
> to belittle the protesters' concerns.
> It's easy to understand how Mr. Bloomberg's background, like Mayor
> Daley's, gave him a distaste for unruly protesters. But that doesn't
> excuse his failure to speak out forcefully about the importance of
> speech. He is mayor of New York now, and one of the New York's
> attributes has always been its openness to robust political debate.
> he rolls out the red carpet for the Republicans, he should make
> that as long as protesters obey the law, they will be just as
> welcome as
> the delegates.
> These are hard times for protesters. Sept. 11 provided an excuse for
> tossing out the Founding Fathers' broad notions of freedom of
> petition and assembly, and for imposing "time, place and manner"
> restrictions that push protests completely out of view. When
> Bush appears in public, the Secret Service now routinely forces
> demonstrators to move to far-off "free speech zones." When the
> attended a gathering of world leaders last month on Sea Island, Ga.,
> protesters were kept 10 miles away.
> As mayor of New York, Mr. Bloomberg has a special duty to resist
> trend. Because if political dissent can't make it here, it can't
> make it
> The Marxism list: www.marxmail.org
> Marxism mailing list
> Marxism at lists.econ.utah.edu
The best thing to hit the Internet in years - Juno SpeedBand!
Surf the Web up to FIVE TIMES FASTER!
Only $14.95/ month - visit www.juno.com to sign up today!
More information about the Marxism