[Marxism] Different periods, different politics

Dayne Goodwin dayneg at aros.net
Mon Mar 8 21:22:12 MST 2004


On Mon, 8 Mar 2004, Louis Proyect wrote:
> Has capitalism won? A reply to Irwin Silber
> Comment by Reihana Mohideen
>
> In his recently published book Socialism: What Went Wrong?, Irwin
> Silber, long-term activist in the US left and editorial member of
> Crossroads magazine, argues that there has been no objective basis for
> socialist revolution this century.


	I don't think that describing Silber as a 'long-term activist' and
reference to his brief involvement with the short-lived Crossroads
magazine is an adequate appreciation of his life-long training in the
Stalinist school of class-collaboration - first the pro-Moscow variant,
then over to the pro-Beijing, then back to pro-Moscow.  I think the
long-term development of his political views is an excellent case-study in
the damage inflicted by a Stalinist political education.
	On the other hand, i'd have to say that Silber had more political
courage than those who grow up in the undisguised schools of reformism.
	Dayne




More information about the Marxism mailing list