[Marxism] US policy in disarray over Fallujah Accord

Fred Feldman ffeldman at bellatlantic.net
Sat May 1 08:18:51 MDT 2004

Washington's attempt to take advantage of a pause in the rise of the
anti-occupation struggle to deal huge blows to the movement appears to
have coming acropper in Fallujah.  

Among other things this is highlighting
divisions in the military ranks, the officers, and the chain of command.
It is beginning to look as though US imperialism has "blinked" in the
battle -- in which thousands have been murdered, jailed, tortured,
bombed and brutally treated by US forces -- but it is certain that
blinking is epidemic at every level below the very top.  

The "Vietnam Syndrome," which has been buried alive more often than Uma
Thurman and
Buffy the Vampire Slayer combined, is now being reinforced and expanded
by a developing "Iraq syndrome."
Fred Feldman


The Scotsman      30 April 2004

Fallujah accord leaves US policy in disarray 

James Hall 
Foreign editor 

The United States' policy on Iraq was in disarray last night, as the
Pentagon admitted it was unaware of a breakthrough agreement to end the
siege of Fallujah announced by its troops on the ground. 

While a new poll showed a majority of Iraqis want US and British troops
to leave in the next few months, an American marine commander revealed
that his troops were preparing to withdraw from the outskirts of
Fallujah, a major U-turn in US policy. 

Lieutenant Colonel Brennan Byrne said a newly created Iraqi force of
1,100 soldiers, called the Fallujah Protective Army and led by a former
general from Saddam Hussein's army, would take over security in the
besieged city. 

It was a deal few of his superiors seemed aware of. 

In Washington, Larry Di Rita, the chief Pentagon spokesman, said:
"There's no deal that we're aware of." He added that he could not rule
out that an agreement was in place, but said that officials at the US
military command in Baghdad told him they could not confirm a final deal
was sealed. 

In Washington, Paul Wolfowitz, the US deputy defence secretary, said the
situation in Fallujah was confusing but a deal was being worked on. 

"The goal has got to be to try to isolate the killers from the
population, so that if military action is necessary, it can be done with
a minimum of civilian casualties," he added. 

To add to the sense of disarray, US marines to the south of Fallujah
were yesterday packing up their kit and destroying earthworks in
apparent preparation for withdrawal. Yet elsewhere in the city,
airstrikes were being launched against insurgent positions and gunfire
could be heard last night. 

The marines' siege of Fallujah is the most controversial military action
undertaken by coalition forces since the end of the war, with Iraqi
doctors estimating that 600 Iraqis had died in the fighting. 

Sunni and Shiite communities alike have expressed their anger at the US
tactics, and members of the coalition-appointed Iraqi Governing Council
have threatened to resign if the fighting continues. Confirmation of the
coalition's unpopularity came yesterday, with the publication of a poll
which showed that, despite concerns about their own safety, the majority
of Iraqis say they want the US and British troops now in Iraq to leave
within the next few months. 

The CNN-USA Today-Gallup poll was taken between 22 March and 9 April,
before the latest rounds of fighting between coalition forces and
insurgents. Yet the results will prove of concern to coalition planners:

. 64 per cent of those polled said actions by the coalition have turned
out worse than they expected at the time of the invasion; 

. 57 per cent said they would like to see coalition troops leave
"immediately, within the next few months", while 36 per cent said they
would like to see those troops stay longer; 

. Seven in ten said they view the US presence as an occupation and not a

. Last August, almost six in ten Iraqis said they had a positive view of
how US troops are behaving. Now, residents of Baghdad view US soldiers
negatively, by almost 8-1; 

. Six in ten of those polled from Sunni areas said the attacks on US
troops can be justified morally. However, six out of ten Iraqis said
ousting Saddam was worth the hardships they have faced since then. 

The situation in Iraq is also causing increased concern in the US as the
death toll mounts. Ten more soldiers died yesterday - eight of them
killed when a car bomb exploded south of Baghdad. 

At least 125 US soldiers have died this month, bringing to 534 the total
number of those killed in action since the invasion in March 2003. 

A new opinion poll in the US has found that support for the war has
fallen substantially over the past few months. After initially
expressing robust backing for the war, the American public is now evenly
divided over whether the military should stay for as long as it takes to
stabilise Iraq, or pull out as soon as possible, the poll showed. 

Asked whether the US had done the right thing in taking military action
against Iraq, 47 per cent of respondents said it had, down from 58 per
cent a month earlier and 63 per cent in December. 

The New York Times/CBS News poll found that 46 per cent of respondents
said the US should have stayed out of Iraq, up from 37 per cent last
month and 31 per cent in December.

More information about the Marxism mailing list