[Marxism] US Chose Mass Murder Over Simple Revenge in Afghanistan
M. Junaid Alam
mjunaidalam at msalam.net
Mon Nov 1 23:55:09 MST 2004
/Give Him an "F" in the War on Terror/
How Bush Was Offered Bin Laden and Blew It
By ALEXANDER COCKBURN
and JEFFREY ST. CLAIR
George Bush, the man whose prime campaign plank has been his ability to
wage war on terror, could have had Osama bin Laden's head handed to him
on a platter on his very first day in office, and the offer held good
until February 2 of 2002. This is the charge leveled by an Afghan
American who had been retained by the US government as an intermediary
between the Taliban and both the Clinton and Bush administrations.
Kabir Mohabbat is a 48-year businessman in Houston, Texas. Born in
Paktia province in southern Afghanistan, he's from the Jaji clan (from
which also came Afghanistan's last king). Educated at St Louis
University, he spent much of the 1980s supervising foreign relations for
the Afghan mujahiddeen, where he developed extensive contacts with the
US foreign policy establishment, also with senior members of the Taliban.
After the eviction of the Soviets, Mohabbat returned to the United
States to develop an export business with Afghanistan and became a US
citizen. Figuring in his extensive dealings with the Taliban in the late
1990s was much investment of time and effort for a contract to develop
the proposed oil pipeline through northern Afghanistan.
In a lengthy interview and in a memorandum Kabir Mohabbat has given us a
detailed account and documentation to buttress his charge that the Bush
administration could have had Osama bin Laden and his senior staff
either delivered to the US or to allies as prisoners, or killed at their
Afghan base. As a search of the data base shows, portions of Mohabbat's
role have been the subject of a number of news reports, including a CBS
news story by Alan Pizzey aired September 25, 2001. This is the first he
has made public the full story.
By the end of 1999 US sanctions and near-world-wide political ostracism
were costing the Taliban dearly and they had come to see Osama bin Laden
and his training camps as, in Mohabbat's words, "just a damn liability".
Mohabbat says the Taliban leadership had also been informed in the
clearest possible terms by a US diplomat that if any US citizen was
harmed as a consequence of an Al Qaeda action, the US would hold the
Taliban responsible and target Mullah Omar and the Taliban leaders.
In the summer of 2000, on one of his regular trips to Afghanistan,
Mohabbat had a summit session with the Taliban high command in Kandahar.
They asked him to arrange a meeting with appropriate officials in the
European Union, to broker a way in which they could hand over Osama bin
Laden . Mohabbat recommended they send bin Laden to the World Criminal
Court in the Hague.
Shortly thereafter, in August of 2000, Mohabbat set up a meeting at the
Sheraton hotel in Frankfurt between a delegation from the Taliban and
Reiner Weiland of the EU. The Taliban envoys repeated the offer to
deport bin Laden. Weiland told them he would take the proposal to Elmar
Brok, foreign relations director for the European Union. According to
Mohabbat, Brok then informed the US Ambassador to Germany of the offer.
At this point the US State Department called Mohabbat and said the
government wanted to retain his services, even before his official
period on the payroll, which lasted from November of 2000 to late
September, 2001, by which time he tells us he had been paid $115,000.
On the morning of October 12, 2000, Mohabbat was in Washington DC,
preparing for an 11am meeting at the State Department , when he got a
call from State, telling him to turn on the tv and then come right over.
The USS Cole had just been bombed. Mohabbat had a session with the head
of State's South East Asia desk and with officials from the NSC. They
told him the US was going to "bomb the hell out of Afghanistan". "Give
me three weeks," Mohabbat answered, "and I will deliver Osama to your
doorstep." They gave him a month.
Mohabbat went to Kandahar and communicated the news of imminent bombing
to the Taliban. They asked him to set up a meeting with US officials to
arrange the circumstances of their handover of Osama. On November 2,
2000, less than a week before the US election, Mohabbat arranged a
face-to-face meeting, in that same Sheraton hotel in Frankfurt, between
Taliban leaders and a US government team.
After a rocky start on the first day of the Frankfurt session, Mohabbat
says the Taliban realized the gravity of US threats and outlined various
ways bin Laden could be dealt with. He could be turned over to the EU,
killed by the Taliban, or made available as a target for Cruise
missiles. In the end, Mohabbat says, the Taliban promised the
"unconditional surrender of bin Laden" . "We all agreed," Mohabbat tells
CounterPunch, "the best way was to gather Osama and all his lieutenants
in one location and the US would send one or two Cruise missiles."
Up to that time Osama had been living on the outskirts of Kandahar. At
some time shortly after the Frankfurt meeting, the Taliban moved Osama
and placed him and his retinue under house arrest at Daronta, thirty
miles from Kabul.
In the wake of the 2000 election Mohabbat traveled to Islamabad and met
with William Milam, US ambassador to Pakistan and the person designated
by the Clinton administration to deal with the Taliban on the fate of
bin Laden. Milam told Mohabbat that it was a done deal but that the
actual bombing of bin Laden would have to be handled by the incoming
On November 23, 2000, Mohabbat got a call from the NSC saying they
wanted to put him officially on the payroll as the US government's
contact man for the Taliban. He agreed. A few weeks later an official
from the newly installed Bush NSC asked him to continue in the same role
and shortly thereafter he was given a letter from the administration
(Mohabbat tells us he has a copy), apologizing to the Taliban for not
having dealt with bin Laden, explaining that the new government was
still setting in, and asking for a meeting in February 2001.
The Bush administration sent Mohabbat back, carrying kindred tidings of
delay and regret to the Taliban three more times in 2001, the last in
September after the 9/11 attack. Each time he was asked to communicate
similar regrets about the failure to act on the plan agreed to in
Frankfurt. This procrastination became a standing joke with the Taliban,
Mohabbat tells CounterPunch "They made an offer to me that if the US
didn't have fuel for the Cruise missiles to attack Osama in Daronta,
where he was under house arrest, they would pay for it."
Kabir Mohabbat's final trip to Afghanistan on the US government payroll
took place on September 3, 2001. On September 11 Mohabbat acted as
translator for some of the Taliban leadership in Kabul as they watched
tv coverage of the attacks on the World Trade Center and the Pentagon.
Four days later the US State Department asked Mohabbat to set up a
meeting with the Taliban. Mohabbat says the Taliban were flown to Quetta
in two C-130s. There they agreed to the three demands sought by the US
team: 1. Immediate handover of bin Laden; 2. Extradition of foreigners
in Al Qaeda who were wanted in their home countries; 3. shut-down of bin
Laden's bases and training camps. Mohabbat says the Taliban agreed to
all three demands.
This meeting in Quetta was reported in carefully vague terms by Pizzey
on September 25, where Mohabbat was mentioned by name. He tells us that
the Bush administration was far more exercised by this story than by any
other event in the whole delayed and ultimately abandoned schedule of
On October 18, Mohabbat tells us, he was invited to the US embassy in
Islamabad and told that "there was light at the en d of the tunnel for
him", which translated into an invitation to occupy the role later
assigned to Karzai. Mohabbat declined, saying he had desire for the role
of puppet and probable fall guy.
A few days later the Pizzey story was aired and Mohabbat drew the ire of
the Bush administration where he already had an enemy in the form of
Zalmay Khalilzad, appointed on September 22 as the US special envoy to
Afghanistan. After giving him a dressing down, US officials told
Mohabbat the game had changed, and he should tell the Taliban the new
terms: surrender or be killed. Mohabbat declined to be the bearer of
this news and went off the US government payroll.
Towards the end of that same month of October, 2001 Mohabbat was
successfully negotiating with the Taliban for the release of Heather
Mercer (acting in a private capacity at the request of her father) when
the Taliban once again said they would hand over Osama Bin Laden
unconditionally. Mohabbat tells us he relayed the offer to David
Donahue, the US consulate general in Islamabad. He was told, in his
words,that "the train had moved". Shortly thereafter the US bombing of
In December Mohabbat was in Pakistan following with wry amusement the
assault on Osama bin Laden's supposed mountain redoubt in Tora Bora, in
the mountains bordering Pakistan. At the time he said, he informed US
embassy officials the attack was a waste of time. Taliban leaders had
told him that Bin Laden was nowhere near Tora Bora but in Waziristan.
Knowing that the US was monitoring his cell phone traffic, Osama had
sent a decoy to Tora Bora.
From the documents he's supplied us and from his detailed account we
regard Kabir Mohabbat's story as credible and are glad to make public
his story of the truly incredible failure of the Bush administration to
accept the Taliban's offer to eliminate Bin Laden. As a consequence of
this failure more than 3,000 Americans and thousands of Afghans died.
Mohabbat himself narrowly escaped death on two occasions when Al Qaeda,
apprised of his role, tried to kill him. In Kabul in February, 2001, a
bomb was detonated in his hotel in Kabul. Later that year, in July, a
hand grenade thrown in his room in a hotel in Kandahar failed to explode.
He told his story to the 9/11 Commission (whose main concern, he tells
us, was that he not divulge his testimony to anyone else), also to the
9/11 Families who were pursuing a lawsuit based on the assumption of US
intelligence blunders by the FBI and CIA. He says his statements were
not much use to the families since his judgment was, and still remains,
that it was not intelligence failures that allowed the 9/11 attacks, but
criminal negligence by the Bush administration.
More information about the Marxism