[Marxism] Precapitalist property relations?

Carrol Cox cbcox at ilstu.edu
Thu Nov 10 13:53:41 MST 2005

Louis Proyect wrote:
> Marx's
> statement that capitalism could have arisen anywhere--not just in Great
> Britain.

Of course it could have originated anywhere. (Perhaps not in Antartica
or Easter Island.) But that is irrelevant to the "Brenner Debate," which
is not what about _could_ have happened but what, _contingently_, did

It's this sort of tautologism that can poison the debate.


More information about the Marxism mailing list