[Marxism] Precapitalist property relations?
cbcox at ilstu.edu
Thu Nov 10 13:53:41 MST 2005
Louis Proyect wrote:
> statement that capitalism could have arisen anywhere--not just in Great
Of course it could have originated anywhere. (Perhaps not in Antartica
or Easter Island.) But that is irrelevant to the "Brenner Debate," which
is not what about _could_ have happened but what, _contingently_, did
It's this sort of tautologism that can poison the debate.
More information about the Marxism