[Marxism] Counterpunch on Bob Woodward

Louis Proyect lnp3 at panix.com
Thu Nov 17 08:11:13 MST 2005

Counterpunch, November 17, 2005
 From Reporter to Courtier
The Decline of Bob Woodward


It's been a devastating fall for what are conventionally regarded as the 
nation's two premier newspapers, the New York Times and the Washington 
Post. The Times's travails and the downfall of its erstwhile star reporter, 
Judy Miller, have been newsprint's prime soap opera since late spring and 
now, just when we were taking a breather before the Libby trial, the 
Washington Post is writhing with embarrassment over the multiple conflicts 
of interest of its most famous staffer, Bob Woodward, best known to the 
world as Nixon's nemesis in the Watergate scandal.

On Monday of this week Woodward quietly made his way to the law office of 
Howard Shapiro, of the firm of Wilmer, Cutler, Pickering, Hale and Doar, 
and gave a two-hour deposition to Plamegate prosecutor Patrick Fitzgerald, 
a man he had denounced on tv the night before Scooter Libby's indictment as 
"a junkyard dog of a prosecutor".

Woodward's deposition had been occasioned by a call to Fitzgerald from a 
White House official on November 3, a week after Libby had been indicted. 
The official told Fitzgerald that the prosecutor had been mistaken in 
claiming in his press conference that Libby had been the first to disclose 
the fact that Joseph Wilson's wife [ie Valerie Plame] was in the CIA. The 
official informed Fitzgerald that he himself had divulged Plame's job to 
Woodward in a mid-June interview, about a week before Libby told Miller the 
same thing.

Seeing his laborious constructed chronology collapse in ruins, weakening 
his case against Libby, Fitzgerald called Woodward that same day, November 
3. Woodward, the Washington Post's assistant managing editor, no doubt 
found the call an unwelcome one, since he had omitted to tell anyone at the 
Post, up to and including editor Len Downie and publisher Donald Graham, 
that he'd been the first journalist to be on the receiving end of a leak 
from the White House about Plame. He'd kept his mouth shut while two of his 
colleagues, Walter Pincus and Glenn Kessler had been hauled before Fitzgerald.

Shortly after the call from Fitzgerald. Woodward told Downie that he would 
have to testify. On Wednesday the Post carried a somewhat acrid news story 
along with Woodward's account of his testimony. Later in the day Howard 
Kurtz posted a commentary on the Post's website. It's clear from the news 
story and Kurtz's piece that his colleagues find Woodward's secretive 
conduct unbecoming (Downie tamely said it was a "mistake") and somewhat 
embarassing, given all the huff and puff about Judy "Miss Run Amok" 
Miller's high-handed ways with her editors.

And just as Miller and her editors differed strongly on whether the 
reporter had told them what she was up to, so too did Woodward's account 
elicit a strenuous challenge from the Post's long-time national security 
correspondent, Walter Pincus.

In Woodward's account of his testimony (which he took care to have vetted 
and later publicly approved by the Post's former editor Ben Bradlee) he 
wrote that he told Fitzgerald that he had shared this information -- 
Plame's employment with the CIA -- with Pincus. But Pincus is adamant that 
Woodward did no such thing. When the Post's reporters preparing Wednesday's 
story quizzed him about Woodward's version Pincus answered, "Are you 
kidding? I certainly would have remembered that."

Pincus told Joe Stroup of Editor & Publisher later on Tuesday that he had 
long suspected that Woodward was somehow entangled in the Plame affair. 
After Fitzgerald was appointed special prosecutor in the fall of 2003 
Woodward had gone to Pincus and asked his colleague, in Pincus's words, "to 
keep him out of the reporting, and I agreed to do that."

Like many others, the Washington Post's staff had vivid memories of 
Woodward's unending belittling of the whole Plame affair as something of 
little consequence,"laughable", "quite minimal". Woodward said it on the 
Larry King show the night before the indictments, almost as if he was 
trying to send Fitzgerald a message.

For months Woodward has been working on a book about Bush's second term. 
The White House, ecstatic at Woodward's highly flattering treatment of Bush 
in Plan of Attack and Bush at War (Washington's retort to the Harry Potter 
series), has been giving Woodward extraordinary access, confident that he 
will put a kindly construction on their disastrous handling of the nation's 

Judy Miller was savaged for accepting what she claimed to be special 
credentials from the Pentagon in return for confidentiality. So what are we 
to say about Woodward, who is given special access and then repays the 
favor by belittling the Plame scandal, while simultaneously concealing his 
own personal knowledge of the White House's schedule on the outing of 
Valerie Plame?

Woodward did not disclose his potential conflict of interest while he was 
pontificating on the airwaves about the Plame affair but he also apparently 
succeeded in stifling an investigation into his own role by his colleague 
Pincus. He may have also placed Pincus in legal jeopardy with his testimony 
to Fitzgerald that he had informed Pincus in June of 2003 about Plame. 
Pincus had testified under oath to Fitzgerald in September of 2004 that his 
first knowledge of Plame's employer had come in a conversation with a White 
House source at a later date.

So who was Woodward's source and what was his motive in calling Prosecutor 
Fitzgerald the week after Libby's indictment to disclose that he had talked 
to Woodward before Libby began his own speed-dial leaking? Woodward says it 
wasn't White House chief of staff Andrew Card. He also says he went to see 
his source with 18 pages of questions, whose topics included yellowcake 
from Niger and the infamous October 2003 National Intelligence Estimate on 
Iraq's alleged WMD.

After this initial interview with a White House official in mid-June 2003, 
Woodward learned enough that when he saw two other White House staffers 
shortly thereafter he had the phrase "Joe Wilson's wife" among his 
questions. So the first official did the leaking. He could well have been 
vice president Cheney, since Woodward's interview took place exactly at the 
time that Cheney's office was buzzing with alarm after a call from Pincus 
telling them he was working on a story about Joe Wilson.

That afternoon Cheney informed Libby that Wilson's wife worked at the CIA. 
Libby spent the next week gathering a dossier on Plame. On June 23 Libby 
and Woodward talked on the phone. Woodward had the 18 pages of questions 
he'd already posed twice, and began to work his way through them. He says 
he can't recall Libby bringing up Plame's name.

It's our guess that Libby, eager to broach Plame's role to the Post's 
renowned investigative reporter, finally wearied on the endless questions, 
cut Woodward off and hastened off to lunch with Miller. Woodward claims he 
kept no notes, and so did Miller until her famous notebook with "Flame" in 
it turned up at the New York Times. All in all it was a bad leak day for 
Scooter, since Woodward wasn't working as a reporter but as 
historian-courtier, and Miller had been taken off the story by her editors.

If Woodward's first source was Cheney, why would the latter have called 
Fitzgerald on November 3? The admission by Cheney that he had spoken to 
Woodward could derail Libby's prosecution and also undercut possible 
charges of a breach of the Espionage act, by playing into the line Woodward 
took on the Larry King Show and elsewhere, that this was no dreadful 
affront to national security but indeed "gossip" and "chatter".

So much for the fortune's wheel. From Nixon's nemesis to Cheney's savior.



More information about the Marxism mailing list