[Marxism] katrina & disenfranchisement
sudhirdin at gmail.com
Thu Nov 17 23:53:57 MST 2005
even the misery of the poor is grist to the mill of the power elite. both
class and race are agaist the hapless victims of katrina, infernally more so
under the current dispensation in bushland.
Voter Disenfranchisement by Attrition With friends like FEMA, who needs Jim
*Benjamin Greenberg In These Times Nov 16, 2005*
When Hurricane Katrina came ashore in New Orleans, it destroyed half the
city's voting precincts and scattered 300,000 of the city's residents, most
of them black, across the country. With citywide elections still scheduled
in February and March for 20 key public offices--including mayor, criminal
sheriff, civil sheriff and all city council members--restoring the city's
democratic capability might seem an urgent task to some, but not to the
Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA).
All evacuees who apply for assistance must tell FEMA who they are, where
they lived before they were displaced and where they live now. Since early
October, Louisiana Secretary of State Al Ater, a Democrat, has been dogging
the agency for the names and temporary addresses of evacuees, so he can send
them information about how to maintain their right to vote in Louisiana.
Because many evacuees are far from New Orleans and cannot make a special
trip home for the elections, their only way to vote will be by absentee
ballot. But, citing privacy concerns, FEMA stonewalled Ater for weeks. They
finally reached an agreement on November 8, but it is an open question if
the compromise will lead to fair elections.
Ater has also requested $750,000 from FEMA for a Nationwide Voter Outreach
and Education Campaign.
"Given the inability of the displaced voters of Louisiana to receive local
election information via their local news, some kind of extraordinary
outreach should be made to educate those voters," says David J. Becker,
election consultant and former senior trial attorney for the voting section
of the U.S. Department of Justice. "Otherwise their voting rights may be yet
another victim of Hurricane Katrina."
Many evacuees have moved several times since they first applied for
assistance, and they may never receive voter information unless they learn
by word of mouth or through the media to contact Ater's office for ballots.
Consequently, Ater is proposing a publicity campaign that would include
direct mail, radio and TV public service announcements, satellite media
tours and travel for himself and staff members to areas with high
concentrations of evacuees.
Why should FEMA pay for this? The Stafford Act, which gives FEMA its role in
coordinating relief efforts, provides that FEMA may make contributions
towards the repair of damaged public facilities and provide "technical and
advisory assistance" for "the performance of essential community services."
On October 5, Ater asked FEMA's liaison to his office, Arvin Schultz, for
FEMA's list of evacuees. Schultz responded On October 14 to Ater's requests
with a terse e-mail, writing that FEMA "will not fund the outreach program.
They will not let you have a copy of the FEMA applicant list. Sorry!!!" Two
days later, Ater appealed to Deputy Federal Coordinating Officer Scott
Wells, the top FEMA official in Louisiana. Ater's appeal was rejected, this
time with the rationale that releasing the list of evacuees would violate
the Privacy Act of 1974.
Ater then went to Washington, D.C., to negotiate with FEMA and lobby
Louisiana's representatives and senators to push the agency to reverse its
decision. He suggested a compromise: FEMA could take the voter rolls from
him and mail the election materials itself to avoid disclosing the evacuees'
addresses. Though FEMA said it wanted to work with Ater, agency officials
dragged their heels for nearly two weeks. FEMA Spokesman Butch Kinerney says
the main problem was "mechanical questions" about the best method for
reaching voters while protecting privacy.
On November 8, FEMA finally made a clear concession. The agency said it
would pay to send a one-page flyer to all evacuees that would explain voting
rights and include ways to contact Ater's office. Yet, Ater still does not
know when FEMA will mail the flyer.
In contrast, the agency responded quickly to share the same information with
law enforcement. At the end of September, Texas law enforcement officials
began asking FEMA for the list of evacuees in order to determine where sex
offenders evacuated from Louisiana might have landed in Texas. By the middle
of October, FEMA declared that while it would not release all of the names
and addresses, it would cross-reference the evacuee list with the sex
offender list for any legitimate law enforcement agency that requests it. In
order to expedite the process, FEMA now provides law enforcement agencies
with a form letter they can use to ask FEMA to identify sex offenders from
Louisiana who have fled to their communities.
Reshaping the Voter Base
Despite FEMA's compromise with Ater, the agency is still flouting the Equal
Protection Clause of the Constitution and the Voting Rights Act of 1965.
Without the means to carry out his Nationwide Voter Outreach and Education
Campaign--and to do so expediently and over enough time to be effective--it
will be impossible for Ater to ensure that thousands of displaced voters do
not face an undue burden in securing their right to vote. The current
mechanism for reaching displaced voters by mail is essential, but it is not
enough. "You can't expect the average person to be an election law expert
and to know what to do," says Ater.
"For lawyers who do voter protection work to ensure that every vote cast is
counted, it's going to be a very challenging election," says Judith Browne,
co-director of the Advancement Project, a group founded to promote racial
justice and democracy, and co-chair of the Legal Committee of the People's
Hurricane Relief Fund and Oversight Coalition, a grassroots movement of
persons disproportionately impacted by the hurricane. "If there is an
absentee ballot campaign, protections must be put into place. There is
concern that the kind of voter suppression we saw directed at people of
color in Ohio in 2004 will be directed at Katrina victims in the upcoming
In Ohio and other states, low-income black voters were vulnerable to
partisan challenges to their registration status because they were least
likely to have identification and most likely to change residences between
Evacuees will be considerably more vulnerable as targets in the upcoming
high-stakes elections. "If the Republican Party had long lists of people to
challenge at the polls in 2004, what kind of action will we see around many
thousands of absentee ballots in 2005 and 2006?" says Browne.
Black voters are not the only ones facing the hardships of relocation, but
they are the group most affected by Katrina. At the end of October, Gallup
released a survey of evacuees that showed that "the differences between
racial groups were, on average, much larger than the differences between
high- and low-income groups." While there are no hard numbers for how many
of the 300,000 New Orleans evacuees are black, it appears to be well over
two-thirds. Pre-Katrina New Orleans had a population of 500,000, of which
nearly 70 percent was black.
Today, the city is down to an estimated 70,000 residents (including contract
workers). The most populated areas are the predominantly white districts
nearest the Mississippi River--Uptown, the Lower Garden District, Warehouse
District, French Quarter, Marigny--while areas such as the Lower Ninth Ward,
which were more than 90 percent black, are being kept near empty by police,
military and paramilitary forces.
With 73 percent of New Orleans residents over the age of 18, according to
Census 2000, roughly 219,000 of the New Orleans evacuees should be of voting
age. If we estimate conservatively that 70 percent of those evacuees are
black, that's 153,300 black voters whose poll tapes FEMA is replacing with
red tape. This is voter disenfranchisement by attrition. There may not be
visible long lines outside of polling places, but the scale is much larger
than anything in Ohio or Florida.
"Many who were residents of New Orleans and who want to go back were not
registered voters," says Browne. "These folks are outraged by the
government's inadequate response to the flooding and are passionate about
these issues now. They want to vote."
Benjamin Greenberg is a poet, journalist, activist and author of the
Blues <http://hungryblues.us/>, which is dedicated to the legacy of his
activist father, Paul Greenberg, former Special Assistant to Dr. Martin
Luther King, Jr. He is also a member of the *Dollars and Sense* Collective.
More information about the Marxism