[Marxism] Michael Walzer

Calvin Broadbent calvinbroadbent at hotmail.com
Fri Oct 28 09:11:34 MDT 2005


Hi,

Thanks for the help Michael, but I don't really understand a word of this. 
Does Walzer suggest that different 'communities' ought to be accorded 
different 'goods' on the basis of their designated membership of that 
community? Does that ministration extend to material goods (the right to 
community healthcare, education, decent employment, and so on)? Or is Walzer 
more concerned wth formal political 'rights and obligations', and 'cultural' 
recognition, neatly bypassing the entire structure of class exploitation and 
racial oppression?

It seems also that whilst Walzer would be more than willing to assent to 
some kind of special recognition of the black 'community', his allegiance to 
American Nationalism (and America as a more or less ideal model of the 
pluralistic society) would ensure his absolute aversion to black nationalism 
in the US.

Frankly, modern mainstream political philosophy is all tedious word games to 
me.


>>>calvinbroadbent at hotmail.com 10/28/05 6:31 AM >>>
Can anyone possibly give the lowdown on American philosopher Michael Walzer.
<<<<<>>>>>

present-day walzer is identified with communitarianism, he has worked at
synthesizing community & pluralist-liberal thinking, he opposes idea of
'universal theory of justice', arguing, instead for principle that he calls
'complex equality' in which separate rules should apply to distribution of
different social goods, thus, development of 'sphere of justice' (title of,
perhaps, his best known work), in sum: different principles of justice
may be appropriate in different areas of life...

_________________________________________________________________
Be the first to hear what's new at MSN - sign up to our free newsletters! 
http://www.msn.co.uk/newsletters





More information about the Marxism mailing list