[Marxism] Comment on "The War Tapes" to my blog

Louis Proyect lnp3 at panix.com
Sat Apr 22 15:11:44 MDT 2006

(At least on the basis of her email id, the commenter appears to be female, 
I might add.)

I came to this site from the link that you posted in the comments of The 
War Tapes blog.  I have to say that this entry has made me more interested 
in the film than the actual film site.  As a National Guardsman, I had been 
whinging about whether or not I really wanted to check this film out.  I 
didn't know if I wanted to see real soldiers being real on camera for the 
world to see.  It made me cringe thinking about it.  For me, there is 
always a conflict of what I want civilians to see of my Army personality 
and what I don't want them to see.  I don't want people to see my soldier 
side as some "other" that is so different from them that they don't 
identify in some way with it.  Soldiers are real people, but when we get 
deployed the "normal" part of our thoughts and behaviors gets altered or 
suspended altogether.  This complexity is difficult to explore using only 
words - I hope that this film has captured at least a bit of this aspect of 
being a soldier.

More information about the Marxism mailing list