[Marxism] Arthur Schlesinger Jr.: "Bush's Thousand Days"

Walter Lippmann walterlx at earthlink.net
Mon Apr 24 08:17:13 MDT 2006

A friend and subscriber of mine passed this on to me earlier today.

Like Brezinski, Arthur Schlesinger was also part of the government in
Washington, and afterwards was and remains an advice-giver to those
in office, if not in power. It's a very good sign that these people today
are warning Bush against a pre-emptive strike against Iran. I think it
is by no means certain that there will be such a strike, and everything
possible should be done to prevent it, including publicizing comments
like these, which can contribute to and build deeper public opposition
to such a strike. While broad public opposition didn't stop Washington
from invading Iraq, the public is looking at these things differently in
light of the revelations of Washington's "weapons of mass destruction"
lies and the rest of the legal "case" which was cooked-up to justify the
invasion and occupation of Iraq. I'm tempted now to put "occupation"
in quotes since it's coming asunder as we watch and write. Someone
of Schlesinger's ilk is trying to frame this as Washington's victory over
the Soviet Union, of course. Schlesinger's, like Brezinski's are voices
which can be heard and circulated widely in official discussion forums
within the United States, and I certainly hope that it is. We can save
discussion and debate over the events of October 1962 for later in a
more leisurely forum.

Walter Lippmann


From: Julie Troup
Sent: Monday, April 24, 2006 5:36 AM
To: The Trouper
Subject: [Norton AntiSpam] Schlesinger Wisdom

The durable historian and New Dealer, Arthur Schlesinger, looks back 
at America's past and warns us about rumored plans for a preventive 
war against Iran.

It's especially ominous because Bush, the born-again mental case, 
believes he sees things that the rest of us don't.
He's also 'the decider' as he told us
the other day.  God help America.

            -- The Trouper

Bush's Thousand Days

By Arthur Schlesinger Jr.
Monday, April 24, 2006; A17

The Hundred Days is indelibly associated with Franklin D. Roosevelt, and the Thousand Days with John F. Kennedy. But as of this week, a thousand days remain of President Bush's last term -- days filled with ominous preparations for and dark rumors of a preventive war against Iran.

The issue of preventive war as a presidential prerogative is hardly new. In February 1848 Rep. Abraham Lincoln explained his opposition to the Mexican War: "Allow the President to invade a neighboring nation, whenever he shall deem it necessary to repel an invasion and you allow him to do so whenever he may choose to say he deems it necessary for such purpose -- and you allow him to make war at pleasure [emphasis added]. . . . If, today, he should choose to say he thinks it necessary to invade Canada to prevent the British from invading us, how could you stop him? You may say to him, 'I see no probability of the British invading us'; but he will say to you, 'Be silent; I see it, if you don't.' "

This is precisely how George W. Bush sees his presidential prerogative: Be silent; I see it, if you don't . However, both Presidents Harry S. Truman and Dwight D. Eisenhower, veterans of the First World War, explicitly ruled out preventive war against Joseph Stalin's attempt to dominate Europe. And in the Cuban missile crisis of October 1962, President Kennedy, himself a hero of the Second World War, rejected the recommendations of the Joint Chiefs of Staff for a preventive strike against the Soviet Union in Cuba.

It was lucky that JFK was determined to get the missiles out peacefully, because only decades later did we discover that the Soviet forces in Cuba had tactical nuclear weapons and orders to use them to repel a U.S. invasion. This would have meant a nuclear exchange. Instead, JFK used his own thousand days to give the American University speech, a powerful plea to Americans as well as to Russians to reexamine "our own attitude -- as individuals and as a nation -- for our attitude is as essential as theirs." This was followed by the limited test ban treaty. It was compatible with the George Kennan formula -- containment plus deterrence -- that worked effectively to avoid a nuclear clash.

The Cuban missile crisis was not only the most dangerous moment of the Cold War. It was the most dangerous moment in all human history.

Never before had two contending powers possessed between them the technical capacity to destroy the planet. Had there been exponents of preventive war in the White House, there probably would have been nuclear war. It is certain that nuclear weapons will be used again.

Henry Adams, the most brilliant of American historians, wrote during our Civil War, "Some day science shall have the existence of mankind in its power, and the human race shall commit suicide by blowing up the world."

But our Cold War presidents kept to the Kennan formula of containment plus deterrence, and we won the Cold War without escalating it into a nuclear war. Enter George W. Bush as the great exponent of preventive war. In 2003, owing to the collapse of the Democratic opposition, Bush shifted the base of American foreign policy from containment-deterrence to presidential preventive war: Be silent; I see it, if you don't. Observers describe Bush as "messianic" in his conviction that he is fulfilling the divine purpose. But, as Lincoln observed in his second inaugural address, "The Almighty has His own purposes."

There stretch ahead for Bush a thousand days of his own. He might use them to start the third Bush war: the Afghan war (justified), the Iraq war (based on fantasy, deception and self-deception), the Iran war (also fantasy, deception and self-deception). There is no more dangerous thing for a democracy than a foreign policy based on presidential preventive war.

Maybe President Bush, who seems a humane man, might be moved by daily sorrows of death and destruction to forgo solo preventive war and return to cooperation with other countries in the interest of collective security. Abraham Lincoln would rejoice.

The writer, a historian, served as an adviser to President John F.Kennedy.

C 2006 The Washington Post Company

More information about the Marxism mailing list