[Marxism] Paulsen's supposedly anti-democratic, anti-labor, Tudehesque line

Ryan Ng diamatrix at hotmail.com
Sun Aug 20 23:13:13 MDT 2006

Einde O'Callaghan wrote:

"This is blatantly obvious - but then in 1914 the imperialists didn't 
consult the social democrats before going to war either."

Um...war credits?

And in the case of the SPD, I hasten to point out, "capitulation to one's 
own imperialist bourgeoisie" involved not simply "lack of clarity on this 
issue" or "social pacifism a la Kautsky," but formal authorization by the 
party majority to continue financing Germany's war efforts. To draw a 
parallel, however tacit, between such treachery, on the one hand - of 
legendary proportions - and the criticisms expressed by some on this list, 
vis-a-vis the Ahmadinejad regime's repression of Iranian workers and 
socialists, on the other; to impute to both a common logic and deduction - 
this, as Proyect put it before (and I must admit to being altogether 
distressed by the essential agreement in which I suddenly find myself with 
our esteemed moderator, on this question at least), is sheer nonsense.

Play Q6 for your chance to WIN great prizes.  

More information about the Marxism mailing list