[Marxism] Looking for common solutions in NI - with London or with Dublin?

Lüko Willms lueko.willms at t-online.de
Sun Dec 10 12:01:39 MST 2006

     On  Thu, 07 Dec 2006 23:22:26 -0800, 
  wrote  Danielle Ni Dhighe 
     on  Re: [Marxism] Reply on Ireland to PF

> At 09:49 AM 12/7/2006, Lüko Willms wrote:
>  >What you prefer not to mention, is that SF advanced the demand to
>  >implement an all-Irish corporate income tax rate of 12% for all the
>  >island, for all 32 counties.
> And how exactly is that radical or even progressive?  In the South, it
> may be liberal reformism and in the North it may be more conservative,
> but it isn't anything like the republican socialism Sinn Fein
> previously claimed to champion nor is it particularly republican. 

  The 17% are the all-British tax rate for the "United Kingdom of Great 
Britain and Northern Ireland" -- Sinn Féin proposed to leave the country 
UK for a common solution with the 26 counties, for an all-Irish tax rate 
of 12%. 

   While I am dead set against all those tax gifts to corporations and 
rich people in Germany, in a Northern Irish parliament, I would vote 
with both hands for for this motion like for any other measure which 
breaks the six counties' union with London and establishes an all-Irish 

   Do you think that Northern Ireland should keep the Union with 
England, maybe out of a workerist illusion that the Union is better for 
the workers? 

> I prefer to see the national liberation struggle and the class
> liberation struggle as completely intertwined.  One can't be
> accomplished without the other.

  That's what the doctrine says. 

  The experience of real struggles says, that you can't achieve neither 
one if one makes the national question to a side issue of an alleged 
class struggle orientation. 

  Your rejection of an all-Irish common corporate tax rate, i.e. your 
preference on Northern Irelands Union with Britain in tax matters is a 
logical consequence of that -- instead of helping to organize the Irish 
workers to a party by and for themselves, you insist on subjecting them 
to British tax laws and rules, i.e. to His Majety's Chancellor of 

Lüko Willms
Frankfurt, Germany
visit http://www.mlwerke.de Marx, Engels, Luxemburg, Lenin, Trotzki in German

More information about the Marxism mailing list