[Marxism] Re: Isaac Deutscher and Marxist history

Einde O'Callaghan einde at gmx.de
Sun Jul 2 16:07:55 MDT 2006

Brian Shannon wrote:

> My contribution is more fitting for the Yahoo SWP forum. But it  started 
> here, so it makes more sense to continue it here.
> Here are the last paragraphs of Breitman's criticism of Joseph  Hansen's 
> review of Isaac Deutscher's "The Prophet Outcast."
> Unfortunately, we don't have Hansen's review of the final volume of  the 
> Deutscher trilogy available, or his reply to Breitman's strong  
> criticism. Perhaps the ETOL people will do that work for us. Of  course, 
> a few libraries have back issues.
No sooner said than done. While off-line over the last few months I've 
been converting large quantities of articles from new international, 
Fopurth international and International Socialist Review into digital 
files, marking them up in HTML and generally preparing them or 
publication in ETOL or MIA.

Quite by coincidence I was working on Hansen's stuff from ISR this 
weekend and it's now all on-line up to January 1968. The Deutscher 
review is at <http://www.marxists.org/archive/hansen/1964/xx/review.htm> 
and Hansen's reply to Breitman is at 

To check out what else is there take a look at the the Joseph hansen 
internet Archive at <http://www.marxists.org/archive/hansen/index.htm>.

Einde O'Callagahn

More information about the Marxism mailing list