[Marxism] Answer attacks UFPJ

cleon42 at yahoo.com cleon42 at yahoo.com
Sat Jul 22 09:50:09 MDT 2006

--- Javier A <javierunderground at yahoo.com> wrote:

> Its seems that Solidarity has a big presence on Marxmail.

Not "big," just "substantial," IMO. ;) Marxmail's aim of a
multi-tendency movement is very much in line with Soli's view...No big
shock there'd be Soli people here.

> What Im 
> curious is what does Soli do in general? I never run into them 
> anywhere. Ive met a couple of members who do union stuff, but it
> seems  really low key stuff like distribution of Labor Notes and
> trying to  materialize their "democracy cacuses" in their locals.

Well, as far as labor goes, we have a lot of people who work in reform
caucuses. It's a little bit more than trying to "materialize" them, in
several cases reform caucus-supported slates have won important local

> Which is fine  but outside of this, where are they what do they do?
> Everybody knows  what ISo does and how they operate. But most groups
> at least have  public forums about political issues, does Soli ever
> do this?

Occasionally. Not often enough, IMO.

> I havent  seen this anywhere in California. I dont mean this
> as attack, but  sincere curiosity. I would like to talk to some
> members about their  perspective of the labor movement and I know Kim
> Moody's book is  supposed to be excellent, but it seems like their
> the ghosts of the  left, present but really not. 

I can't speak for California, where we have two branches (LA & Bay

In Atlanta, we have people very much involved in union work, organizing
at some local hotels, Palestine solidarity work (particularly yours
truly), anti-war work, the Greens, the immigrant rights movement, all
sorts of stuff. I believe we are currently the largest organized Left
tendency in Atlanta.

Yeah, we're not as high-profile as the ISO. We don't have nearly as
many people, we don't hawk newspapers, and we rarely have lit tables.
That doesn't mean we're not out there.


More information about the Marxism mailing list