[Marxism] Re: The Kurdish question

Louis Proyect lnp3 at panix.com
Wed Mar 29 16:33:03 MST 2006


Nick H. wrote:
>BG:
>
> > Halliday comes to light with an argument that seems to amount to highly
> > speculative proposition that a combination of the resistance and a
> > category he regards as important, Islamicist Kurds, may reconquer the
> > whole of Iraq. Halliday can correct me if I've misinterpreted his view.
>
>Well Bob the biggest speculation I could make would be that you know
>much of anything at all about Iraq or its Kurds. I'm sorry for that
>speculation. As for bad paraphrase amounting to bad argument, sure,
>it's been done a lot on this and other lists like this. It doesn't
>much impress or phase me.

I have a feeling this is from a debate on another list. I can find nothing 
from Bob Gould that includes the excerpt above. For the sake of clarity, 
let's try to avoid this sort of thing. 





More information about the Marxism mailing list