[Marxism] Bullet43: "Against War: Resisting Empire and the Canadian Mission in Afghanistan"

Pance Stojkovski pance at rogers.com
Mon Feb 19 22:42:14 MST 2007

Against War: Resisting Empire and the Canadian Mission in Afghanistan

**York Ad Hoc Committee Against the War**

It is now five years since Canadian troops were first deployed to
Afghanistan, entering from the outset into a combat position. Canada moved
into a war in Afghanistan without any Parliamentary sanction or debate. The
Liberal government of Prime Minister Jean Chretien engineered both an
endorsement and accommodation to the American 'war on terror' by moving into
Afghanistan without directly supporting the American invasion and occupation
of Iraq. The policy was a classic case of Canada trying to have it both
ways. The Canadian mission in Afghanistan was thus begun with neither wide
discussion and even minimal accountability nor strategic thought. It was
undertaken to affirm Canada as the American empire's key ally. In this case,
Canada would act would support U.S. and western imperialism under the rubric
of a NATO mission given legitimacy by a resolution rammed through the UN
Security Council in the wake of 9/11, when rational and calm debate and
analysis was completely foregone. 

Prime Ministers Paul Martin and Stephen Harper both subsequently raised
Canada's commitments to the Afghanistan mission in terms of troop levels,
arms expenditures, and operational deployments. Notably, Canada moved into a
forward combat position in Southern Afghanistan in the winter of 2006 to
directly engage Taliban forces. Canada is scheduled to play a larger role in
the NATO command structure. Relative to domestic population levels, more
Canadians have been killed in Afghanistan than any other of the NATO allies.
And more Canadian soldiers, as well as civilian officials, will be killed in
the coming months, given the chaos that is continuing to spiral upward in
Afghanistan and, indeed, across the Middle East.

There are other disturbing aspects of the Canadian deployment that the
government of Canada has been less than forthcoming about. Canada will soon
be at war in Afghanistan as long as any war Canada has fought in, notably WW
II. The Canadian mission is primarily combat and not development-related,
with only about 10 percent of expenditures being related to development
work. The Karzai government in Kabul being defended has no real democratic
mandate. It is a cesspool of corruption, with aid moneys transferred and
taxes collected soon vanishing into any number of pockets. The so-called
Afghan parliament is full of ex-Taliban and warlords. The government is
making next to no progress on women's and human rights. The Canadian Senate
Standing Committee on National Security and Defence, in its February report,
"Canadian Troops in Afghanistan: Taking a Hard Look at A Hard Mission", came
to most of these same conclusions.

It all but admitted that the war cannot be 'won' (in the eyes of a foreign
military force intervening in another country). But the Senators then
illogically concluded that Canada must stick it out because of the need to
support NATO allies and for peace and security. Yet, the Senate Report
itself had just observed what is apparent to all but the willfully ignorant:
the war and conflict is spreading, as is the range and violence of various
terrorist acts. It is the ideological need to support NATO, as one of the
foremost institutions of western militarism and imperialism, re-engineered
in the post-cold war period to project military power into wayward states in
the 'global south', that remains at the heart of the Canadian intervention
in Afghanistan. When a mission lacks justification and is faltering, as with
the Canadian and NATO mission in Afghanistan, all that is left is for the
bankrupt rulers to assert, as they so often have in the past, that 'war is

The Canadian war in Afghanistan has been barely discussed in Parliament,
with only the briefest debate in May 2006 on a motion extending the Canadian
mission. A much deeper process of discussion, education, and mobilization
needs to ensue across Canada. The Canadian Peace Alliance and other peace
groups have called for nation-wide demonstrations across Canada for March
17. We must begin to work toward that now in our workplaces and communities
across the country. 

We are supporting an anti-war teach-in at York University on February
22 as part of this process. And we are calling on university, college and
high school campuses across Canada to engage in similar teach-ins. Anti-war
activists, students and professors, workers and all citizens simply
concerned with democracy, peace, international restraints on militarism, and
democratic sovereignty must work to build a wide opposition against the war.
We need to bring Canadian troops home and get them out of Afghanistan, and
get NATO and American troops out of Iraq and the Middle East.

  Read complete bullet here:


More information about the Marxism mailing list