[Marxism] is cuba done with equality?

MICHAEL YATES mikedjyates at msn.com
Fri Jun 20 10:49:32 MDT 2008

David says "Isn't saying that worker productivity cannot be measured a bit too extreme? For instance, wouldn't it be possible to make at least very well-educated approximations through the use of input-output tables as suggested in _towards a new socialism_ to determine the labour embodied in each commodity? If labour productivity is a completely elusive concept, is it even possible to lay down a rational plan?"Maybe there is a confusion here.  It is probably not possible to measure an individual's productivity.
Production is evermore collective in nature.  What would it mean to say that steelworker A
is more productive than steelworker B?  Or that hospital workers are as a group less 
productive than coal miners?  Worse still to use comparisons like these to determine
However, it is possible to estimate the labor time needed to produce a ton of steel,
given current technology.  This has nothing to do with a worker's productiveness.  
So aggregate planning is possible. and you could use your input output tables to 
see where you might be able to try to make a process
more productive.  Of course you have to have ways to estiamte the social costs 
of any change (environmental damage for example).
Michael Yates

More information about the Marxism mailing list