[Marxism] Hungarian Roma scapegoated

Louis Proyect lnp3 at panix.com
Mon Apr 27 07:51:44 MDT 2009

NY Times, April 27, 2009
As Economic Turmoil Mounts, So Do Attacks on Hungary’s Gypsies

TISZALOK, Hungary — Jeno Koka was a doting grandfather and dedicated 
worker on his way to his night-shift job at a chemical plant last week 
when he was shot dead at his doorstep. To his killer, he was just a 
Gypsy, and that seems to have been reason enough.

Prejudice against Roma — widely known as Gypsies and long among Europe’s 
most oppressed minority groups — has swelled into a wave of violence. 
Over the past year, at least seven Roma have been killed in Hungary, and 
Roma leaders have counted some 30 Molotov cocktail attacks against Roma 
homes, often accompanied by sprays of gunfire.

But the police have focused their attention on three fatal attacks since 
November that they say are linked. The authorities say the attacks may 
have been carried out by police officers or military personnel, based on 
the stealth and accuracy with which the victims were killed.

In addition to Mr. Koka’s death, there were the slayings of a Roma man 
and woman, who were shot after their house was set ablaze last November 
in Nagycsecs, a town about an hour’s drive from Tiszalok in northeastern 
Hungary. And in February, a Roma man and his 4-year-old son were gunned 
down as they tried to escape from their home, which was set on fire in 
Tatarszentgyorgy, a small town south of Budapest.

Jozsef Bencze, Hungary’s national police chief, said in an interview on 
Friday with the daily newspaper Nepszabadsag that the perpetrators, 
believed to be a group of four or more men in their 40s, were killing 
“with hands that are too confident.” Military counterintelligence is 
taking part in the investigation, Hungarian radio reported, and Mr. 
Bencze said the pool of suspects included veterans of the Balkan wars 
and Hungarian members of the French Foreign Legion.

Experts on Roma issues describe an ever more aggressive atmosphere 
toward Roma in Hungary and elsewhere in Central and Eastern Europe, led 
by extreme right-wing parties, whose leaders are playing on old 
stereotypes of Roma as petty criminals and drains on social welfare 
systems at a time of rising economic and political turmoil. As 
unemployment rises, officials and Roma experts fear the attacks will 
only intensify.

“One thing to remember, the Holocaust did not start at the gas 
chambers,” said Lajos Korozs, senior state secretary in the Ministry of 
Social Affairs and Labor, who works on Roma issues for the government.

In the Czech Republic, where radical right-wing demonstrators have 
clashed with the police as they tried to march through Roma 
neighborhoods, a small child and her parents were severely burned after 
assailants firebombed their home in the town of Vitkov this month. The 
police in Slovakia were caught on video recently tormenting six Roma 
boys they had arrested, forcing them to undress, hit and kiss one another.

But nowhere has the violence reached the level it has in Hungary, 
spreading fear and intimidation through a Roma population of roughly 
600,000. (Estimates vary widely in part because Roma say they are afraid 
to identify themselves in surveys.)

Last Wednesday, Mr. Koka, 54, had just finished a cup of coffee and 
brought his wife supper in their bedroom when he went outside to start 
his orange Opel Astra for his nightly drive to work. His wife, Eva, said 
she heard his body hit the ground, but did not realize it until she went 
outside and found him lying in a pool of blood a few paces from the 

“I tried to lift his hand and his head, but he didn’t say a word,” said 
Ms. Koka, whose brother rushed over from his home across the street and 
tried to perform CPR on Mr. Koka, who had been shot in the chest. “If he 
had not been dead he would have said goodbye to me,” Ms. Koka said in an 
interview at their home.

Viktoria Mohacsi, a Roma member of the European Parliament, said the 
police — who still decline to explicitly name ethnicity as a motive in 
the cases — were slow to recognize the blossoming violence against the 
community. “At the beginning, they said it was illegal money lenders or 
that it was Roma killing each other,” Ms. Mohacsi said, as she visited 
the Koka family here in Tiszalok on Friday.

“In the past five years, attitudes toward Roma in many parts of Eastern 
Europe have hardened, and new extremists have started to use the Roma 
issue in a way that either they didn’t dare to or didn’t get an airing 
before,” said Michael Stewart, coordinator of the Europe-wide Roma 
Research Network.

The extreme-right party Jobbik has used the issue of what its leaders 
call “Gypsy crime” to rise in the polls to near the 5 percent threshold 
for seats in Hungary’s Parliament in next year’s election, which would 
be a first for the party. Opponents accuse the Hungarian Guard, the 
paramilitary group associated with the party, of staging marches and 
public meetings to stir up anti-Roma sentiment and to intimidate the 
local Roma population.

The group held a rally last year in Tiszalok and in 2007 in 
Tatarszentgyorgy, the town where the father and son were killed in 
February, an act that some residents deplored while in the same breath 
complaining about a spate of break-ins in town that they blamed on Roma.

“The situation is bad because of the many Roma,” said Eva, 45, a 
non-Roma Hungarian in Tatarszentgyorgy who declined to give her last 
name, out of what she said was fear of reprisals. “When the guard was 
here, for a while they weren’t so loud. It helped.”

Since the attacks in Tatarszentgyorgy, some local residents have joined 
their terrified Roma neighbors in nighttime patrols, looking for strange 
cars armed with nothing but searchlights.

“We are living in fear, all the Roma people are,” said Csaba Csorba, 48, 
whose son Robert, 27, and grandson, also named Robert, were killed by a 
blast from a shotgun shortly after midnight in the February attack. They 
were buried together in one coffin, the little boy laid to rest on his 
father’s chest.

The child’s death in particular shook Roma here. “It proved to us it 
doesn’t matter whether we are good people or bad people,” said Agnes 
Koka, 32, the niece and goddaughter of Mr. Koka, who relatives said 
loved to bring candy and fruit to his grandchildren. “It only matters 
that we are Gypsy,” Ms. Koka said.

More information about the Marxism mailing list