[Marxism] “These jobs aren’t coming back”

J Rothermel jayroth6 at cox.net
Tue Mar 17 20:55:48 MDT 2009


  Capitalist bosses plan permanent job loss

By Fred Goldstein
Published Mar 12, 2009 8:46 PM

The loss of 651,000 more jobs in February and the jump in the official 
unemployment rate to 8.1 percent have produced important admissions in 
the capitalist press that every worker should pay close attention to.

The New York Times, one of the most important voices of U.S. big 
business in the United States and around the world, ran a lead story on 
March 7 showing that at least 650,000 jobs have been lost in each of the 
last three months—for a total of 4.4 million jobs in all since the 
downturn started in December 2007. In the last four months, 2.6 million 
jobs have disappeared.

But the important point of the story was the prominently placed quote 
from John E. Silvia, chief economist at Wachovia bank: “These jobs 
aren’t coming back,” said Silvia. “A lot of production either isn’t 
going to happen at all, or it’s going to happen somewhere other than the 
United States. There are going to be fewer stores, fewer factories, 
fewer financial services operations.”

“The acceleration,” concluded the Times, “has convinced some economists 
that, far from an ordinary downturn after which jobs will return, the 
contraction under way reflects a fundamental restructuring of the 
American economy.” [Editor’s note: This sentence was pulled from the 
story in the late edition of the Times. However, the headline still 
contained this phrase: “Experts See Rapid Drop as Sign of Permanent 

The auto industry is cited as an example. Car sales have dropped from 17 
million annually a few years ago to 9 million today. “Even if sales 
increase to 10 or 12 million, that still leaves a lot of unneeded 
factories,” said the Times. And Silvia put it bluntly: “That’s a lot of 
workers that are not coming back. That’s a lot of steel, a lot of 
rubber, a lot of suppliers that are not coming back.”

*What overproduction means*

The market for autos is not shrinking because people need fewer autos. 
On the contrary, tens of millions of workers without cars or with cars 
that are broken down, who live in rural areas or in areas with poor or 
no mass transportation, desperately need autos.

U.S. capitalism has built its transit system based upon highways and 
roads. The public transportation system has been starved at the behest 
of the auto bosses and the oil and tire industries. Consequently, in 
most areas of the U.S. an automobile is essential to get and keep a job, 
to shop, to visit, etc. But tens of millions of people earning low wages 
or who are jobless cannot afford to buy cars at a price that will give 
the auto barons a profit.

Capitalism is now suffering from a crisis of overproduction—not 
overproduction of what people need but of what can be sold at a profit. 
This is not only in the auto industry but in housing, commercial real 
estate, electronics, appliances and so on.

While there has been little talk about the growth in the permanent army 
of unemployed planned by the capitalist class, it is implied by their 
own predictions. In fact, as noted in Workers World of March 12, the 
Obama administration’s most optimistic scenario for a recovery of the 
economy—growth of 3.4 percent by 2010—still calculates that there would 
be 7.9 percent unemployment. In other words, the recovery would be a 
recovery for the capitalists but the workers will still be facing mass 
unemployment, approximately at the level it is today.

And this is the optimistic viewpoint!

This is a virtual admission, without saying so, that capitalism from now 
on cannot function without growing mass unemployment of a permanent 
character. Add to this the projection that 8 million people will be 
facing foreclosure in the next few years.

This makes it clear that the bosses, the bankers, the mortgage brokers 
and Wall Street in general are planning to deepen the war on the working 
class and the oppressed. And it is equally clear that the workers must 
gear up, get organized and plan a counteroffensive against this brutal 
campaign of layoffs, foreclosures, evictions and cutbacks.

*Perfect storm engulfs the globe*

The present crisis is a global crisis. U.S. capitalism is the center of 
world capitalism. It is financially, industrially and militarily 
dominant and every thread in the world capitalist economy is tied in 
some way to Wall Street—from Berlin to Bangkok, from Mumbai to Manila, 
from Rome to Rio. All the symptoms now exhibited in the U.S. are being 
reproduced worldwide, often on an even more drastic scale.

The present crisis represents a perfect economic storm in which the 
factors of long-term growth that have propelled U.S. capitalism forward 
over the last 70 years have gone into reverse. But unlike a perfect 
storm in nature, which is random, this perfect storm is driven by the 
fundamental contradictions of the predatory capitalist profit system of 

Private property has come into extreme contradiction with the vast 
socialized apparatus of global production created by capital itself in 
pursuit of profit. The system can no longer be propped up by violent 
militarism and other artificial means, as it has in the past.

The growth of militarism, the scientific-technological revolution, the 
globalization of capitalist exploitation and superexploitation, the 
creation of fictitious capital and credit, the relentless pauperization 
of the working class—all these factors artificially kept capitalist 
accumulation and profits going for generations after the Great 
Depression. But now they have run their course.

*Wars used to stimulate economy*

How did U.S. capitalism emerge from the collapse of the Depression and 
sustain itself for 70 years? The fundamental turning point was World War 
II. After the 1929 to 1933 crisis subsided, there was an upturn in 1934 
which lasted until October of 1937. But then came a profound second 
crash that frightened the Roosevelt administration and the ruling class.

World War II was the historic turning point that opened up a new phase 
of U.S. capitalist development. It choked off a prerevolutionary 
development among the working class in a period of furious class 
struggle and restarted a moribund system.

There was a turn toward war preparation, the beginning of the 
militarization of the economy. Then came the war itself. The massive war 
production—tanks, jeeps, planes, ships, uniforms, food, etc.—restarted 
capitalism. When the smoke cleared, more than 50 million people were 
dead. Europe and much of Asia were in ruins. Massive means of production 
had been destroyed as well as residential buildings, bridges, railroads, 
roads, dams, canals, ports and so forth.

In the period since World War II, U.S. capitalism has relied on various 
artificial methods to keep the system from collapsing. War and war 
preparation were a basic stimulant for decades during the post-war 
period. The Korean War, the Vietnam War, the military buildup during the 
Cold War—all served to generate capitalist production and profits, as 
the system could not rely on the civilian economy to automatically keep 
it going. But by the end of the 1980s, even the $2 trillion Reagan 
military buildup in a “full court press” to undermine the Soviet Union 
and the socialist camp was insufficient to sustain capitalist prosperity.

The continuous development of the scientific-technological revolution, 
the restructuring of capitalist industry, the relentless anti-labor 
campaign of union-busting, extracting concessions, destroying benefits, 
driving down manufacturing wages and steadily expanding the low-wage 
service economy—all this enormously increased inequality in the national 
income in favor of capital at the expense of the workers. All this 
served to bolster profitability for the bosses and bankers.

The collapse of the USSR and Eastern Europe in the 1990s and the opening 
up of China to capitalist investment gave imperialism a brief period of 
unprecedented global expansion. The monopolies seized this opportunity 
to create global networks of exploitation and vast superprofits as they 
engineered a worldwide wage competition among the international working 
class and promoted a vicious race to the bottom.

The structure of globalized production has now turned into an epidemic 
of globalized layoffs and mass unemployment, from Eastern Europe to the 
Baltic states, from east and south Asia to Latin America.

To keep the system going, militarism, technological development and 
anti-labor attacks were supplemented by borrowing, financial injections 
to save banks and corporations, speculation, credit bubbles, mortgage 
schemes, exotic financial instruments and all manner of fraudulent 
schemes to make profits based on trading in fictitious capital.

*Crisis deepens despite militarism*

In the present crisis, none of these measures are available to restart 
the system in any significant way. The two wars underway are draining 
the coffers of U.S. imperialism. Overall militarization has largely been 

New rounds of military development are technology intensive, such as 
laser-guided bombs, satellite-guided missiles, predator drones, 
high-tech missile ships and fighter planes. Current imperialist wars are 
limited and heavily dependent on air power.

Although the trillion dollars (open and hidden) spent annually on the 
military is essential to the system, the size of the capitalist economy 
has grown and any significant stimulus through military expansion would 
have to be on a much greater scale than is possible at the moment.

Only a massive war mobilization on a vast scale for a catastrophic 
military adventure could hold the prospect of diverting the crisis. This 
long-run danger to all humanity is inherent in this crisis.

The long period of creating low-wage capitalism, with a working class in 
debt and living closer and closer to the poverty level, has intensified. 
As this trend deepens it only further aggravates the crisis of 
overproduction by further reducing the buying power of the masses.

And, of course, the credit option has completely run its course as a 
mechanism for reviving capitalist accumulation on a vast scale.

The recent period of technological development has raised the cost of 
capital and made it so productive that the last recovery of 2002 to 
2004, following the dot-com technology bust, was a “jobless recovery” 
during which almost 600,000 jobs were lost! This is what led the banks 
and the Federal Reserve, with the complicity of the Securities and 
Exchange Commission and the Treasury Department, to foster the housing 

Capitalism has reached a point where, even if the trillions of dollars 
that the ruling class is spending in an attempt to mitigate the crisis 
were to result in a revival, it would be weak and short lived, leaving 
many millions unemployed. Capitalism is entering a period of permanent 
and deepening crisis for the masses.

In the present crisis the historic methods of reviving the profitability 
of capitalism, of restoring capitalist accumulation and prosperity, 
appear to have run their course, as they did leading up to the Great 
Depression. This is what has the ruling class running scared.

Working class leaders, labor leaders, community organizers and activists 
in all spheres must come to grips with the prospect that there is no way 
out of the crisis except for mass intervention and mass struggle.

The multinational working class must interfere with the automatic 
processes of capitalist crisis. The layoffs must be stopped. The 
foreclosures and evictions must be stopped. The wage cuts and short 
hours must be stopped. Food must be available for all, no matter what. 
Medical care must be made available to the masses. And this can only be 
achieved by unified mass mobilization and struggle. There is no other 
way, all the stimulus packages and bailouts notwithstanding.

Ultimately the movement must regroup ideologically and recognize that it 
is the capitalist system that has brought the multinational working 
class and much of the middle class to the brink of ruin.

The only way out of the crisis is to liquidate capitalism itself, which 
can only be done by the workers and the oppressed taking into their own 
hands the economic powerhouse they have built and putting it on a 
socialist basis—that is, creating a system that functions to satisfy 
human need rather than to produce profits for a privileged few.

More information about the Marxism mailing list