[Marxism] Moderator's note

Louis Proyect lnp3 at panix.com
Tue Sep 29 12:13:35 MDT 2009

S. Artesian wrote:
> Believe me, I'm not trying to provoke you.  I get no pleasure out of your 
> histrionics.  I do think your views are absolutely anti-thetical to Marxism; 

As a reminder, we should avoid formulations like "antithetical to 
Marxism" here. You are of course permitted to hold such views about 
other comrades, but should refrain from voicing them publicly. It is 
best to simply present your views without trying to characterize your 
ideological adversary. Finally, it seems to me that Nestor and Sartesian 
have debated these points many times in the past with neither comrade 
budging an inch. Debates tend to be more fruitful here when there is 
give-and-take, admitting that the outlook for this being rather dim when 
the participants have been veterans of 30 years or more of hard-line 

More information about the Marxism mailing list