[Marxism] More on the 'Anti-German' Idiocy

Einde O'Callaghan eindeoc at freenet.de
Sun Dec 9 15:18:14 MST 2012

On 09.12.2012 22:14, Angelus Novus wrote:
> ======================================================================
> Rule #1: YOU MUST clip all extraneous text when replying to a message.
> ======================================================================
> Paul Flewers wrote:
>> still lurks around the German left in respect of the prevalence of
>> pro-Zionism
> Yeah, again, this is nothing that originated with the Anti-Germans.  You can consult Ulrike Meinhof's earliest writings to see that it was fairly uncontroversial that the pre-67 New Left in Germany was basically supportive of Israel.  In fact, if I'm not mistaken, Noam Chomsky writes in _The Fateful Triangle_ that pre-67, pro-Israel sentiment was fairly widespread in the New Left internationally.
> Then there were debates around the time of the first Intifada in the mid-80s concerning the legacy of anti-Semitism in the extra-parliamentary left of the 70s, which is largely unknown to people who aren't familiar with the history of the post-war (West-)German left.  Incidents like the Tupamaros West Berlin planning to bomb the Jewish Community Center, or one part of the Revolutionary Cells engaging in a separation of hostages into "Jewish" and "non-Jewish" during an Air France hijacking.
> All of this is completely unfamiliar to most British and American leftists, since in the British and American context, "anti-Semitism" is usually just a cudgel wielded to silence criticism of Israel, whereas in the German left of the 1970s and early 80s, there were actually very real, very ugly manifestations of anti-Semitism, and the autonomist milieu of the 80s and early 90s was engaged in a critical process of processing those experiences.
> It gives too much credit to the Anti-Germans to assume they had much of anything to do with it.  All they ever did was introduced obfuscatory jargon and idiotic "theory" into the discussion, like the completely bananas notion of any criticism of finance being a "structural anti-Semitism" (for a good critique of this bonkers notion, see Gerhard Hanloser's piece here: <http://communism.blogsport.eu/2011/07/18/attac-the-critique-of-globalization-and-structural-antisemitism/> )
All I can say is that the arguments I've encountered again and again 
both in the Antifa and in and around DIE LINKE within the former GDR 
aren't a re-hash of the arguments in the West German left during the 
1970s or 1980s but more or less watered-down versions of the hardline 
anti-German arguments developed around Jungle World and Bahamas.

>> which has a grip in the Left Party. He added that a move to expel the
>> hard-line pro-Zionists from the Left Party was defeated
> It's been a while since I took a look at the party program, but I'm fairly certain the position on Israel and Palestine is standard peace movement boilerplate, support for the rights of both peoples to live in peace and security, a full withdrawal of Israel to the 67 borders and compliance with UN resolutions, dismantling of all settlements, etc.  Basically, what folks like Chomsky and Finkelstein demand.  This is more or less the consensus position.
You're more or less right about the party programme, it's more or less 
the same as the consensus position within the German peace movement. But 
sections of the FDS (Realos) - going beyond the "anti-German" spectrum - 
wanted to include a statement defending "Israel's right to exist" and 
they haven't gone away - but this probably had more to do with their 
desire to be accepted as a possible coalition partner by the SPD and the 
Greens than with any question of principle. And the attacks by some not 
unimportant party members on Inge Höger, a Bundestag member who was on 
the Mavi Marmara when it was stormed by Israeli commandos, were 
particularly vicious.

Einde O'Callaghan

More information about the Marxism mailing list