[Marxism] BDS controversy at Brooklyn COllege

Louis Proyect lnp3 at panix.com
Fri Feb 1 07:24:51 MST 2013

NY Times January 31, 2013
Appearance by Group Advocating Boycott of Israel Roils Brooklyn College

Brooklyn College, in the Midwood neighborhood, would seem an unlikely 
place for Jewish students to feel besieged. Nearly a fifth of the 
undergraduate population is Jewish, and the college, at the heart of a 
once predominantly Jewish area, has produced a long line of prominent 
Jewish graduates.

Enter B.D.S., an international lobbying movement that advocates Israel’s 
withdrawal from Palestinian territories — a demand that caused a furor 
in another unlikely enclave of Brooklyn last year when members of the 
Park Slope Food Co-op rejected a motion to boycott Israeli products.

Next week, two leading voices of B.D.S., which stands for “Boycott, 
Divestment and Sanctions,” are scheduled to speak at the college at an 
event cosponsored by a student group and the college’s political science 
department, prompting a furious response from pro-Israel groups on 
campus and others who say the department’s sponsorship amounts to tacit 

“You do not have a right, and should not put the name of Brooklyn 
College on hate,” said William C. Thompson Jr., the former city 
comptroller, who is running for mayor, at a news conference with more 
than a dozen elected officials, students and B.D.S. opponents outside 
the campus on Thursday. “They should be heard, but not with the official 
stamp of this college.”

The department’s decision — made after a vote by its professors — has 
brought condemnation and praise.

On one side are Alan Dershowitz, the prominent Harvard Law School 
professor, who published a column in The Huffington Post criticizing the 
sponsorship as academically biased, and the Anti-Defamation League; on 
the other are a left-leaning group, Jewish Voices for Peace, and leaders 
of the college and its parent, the City University of New York.

Supporters of the department argue that whatever their personal distaste 
for B.D.S.’s views, academic freedom and freedom of speech allow the 
college to host controversial guests. (The two speakers, Judith Butler, 
a philosopher, and Omar Barghouti, are cosponsored by several student 
and nonstudent groups in addition to the department.)

“The term ‘endorsement’ has been bandied about,” Jeremy Thompson, a 
college spokesman, said soon after speakers at the protest accused the 
college’s president, Karen Gould, and the political science department 
of implicitly endorsing B.D.S.’s point of view and “making it kosher.” 
He said the administration encouraged students to hold events that 
express competing views.

In an e-mail on Thursday, Ms. Butler said she believed it was “terribly 
wrong” to call B.D.S. a hate group, and praised the college for honoring 
academic freedom. “My own aim next Thursday remains the same: to 
consider some of the debates for and against B.D.S. in this public forum 
provided by Brooklyn College, to clarify my viewpoint, and consider 
carefully challenges from the audience,” she said.

Controversial speakers are nothing new on campus, including David 
Horowitz, the conservative pro-Israel commentator, who spoke in March 
2011, though not as a departmental guest.

“Cosponsorship of an event doesn’t necessarily mean endorsement of a 
movement,” Mr. Thompson said.

Assemblyman Dov Hikind, an Orthodox Jew and a Brooklyn College alumnus, 
had not seen it that way. Speaking at Thursday’s protest, Mr. Hikind 
said he believed the college was implicitly supporting B.D.S.

At one point, the student group hosting the event, Students for Justice 
in Palestine, changed the language describing the department’s role on 
its online flier from “cosponsored” to “endorsed,” raising Mr. Hikind’s 
suspicions. It was later changed back to “cosponsored.”

He said that he and the other opponents of the event were supporters of 
free speech, explaining that he did not object to the event itself, only 
the department’s sponsorship of it.

Other speakers were even more strident: “We’re talking about the 
potential for a second Holocaust here,” said Assemblyman Alan Maisel of 

Pro-Israel groups have demanded that the political science department 
also bring in a pro-Israel speaker, but the department has not 
responded, said Ahuva Kohanteb, 21, the president of the Israel Club. 
She said she did not want to mount a public attack on the department 
because she was a political science major.

“That’s going to put a target on my back,” she said.

Ms. Kohanteb’s anxiety reflects what several protesters called the 
“chilling effect” that the department’s decision would have on Jewish 
students on campus, who, the protesters said, might silence their own 
views for fear of angering their professors.

Toby Sklar, a junior, who is Jewish, recalled how one of her political 
science professors had explained in a lecture that she had voted for the 
event to promote “an open marketplace of ideas.” Ms. Sklar would have 
raised her hand to argue, she said, but it was only the second day of 
class and she did not want to antagonize the professor so early.

“I’m not afraid of arguing,” she said. “But it’s an uncomfortable 
feeling to be in class with a professor who voted for it.”

More information about the Marxism mailing list