[Marxism] Peak water

Louis Proyect lnp3 at panix.com
Fri Jan 31 08:00:12 MST 2014

NY Times, Jan 31 2014
Its Great Lake Shriveled, Iran Confronts Crisis of Water Supply

LAKE URMIA, Iran — After driving for 15 minutes over the bottom of what 
was once Iran’s largest lake, a local environmental official stepped out 
of his truck, pushed his hands deep into his pockets and silently 
wandered into the great dry plain, as if searching for water he knew he 
would never find.

Just an hour earlier, on a cold winter day here in western Iran, the 
official, Hamid Ranaghadr, had recalled how as recently as a decade ago, 
cruise ships filled with tourists plied the lake’s waters in search of 
flocks of migrating flamingos.

Now, the ships are rusting in the mud and the flamingos fly over the 
remains of the lake on their way to more hospitable locales. According 
to figures compiled by the local environmental office, only 5 percent of 
the water remains.

Iran is facing a water shortage potentially so serious that officials 
are making contingency plans for rationing in the greater Tehran area, 
home to 22 million, and other major cities around the country. President 
Hassan Rouhani has identified water as a national security issue, and in 
public speeches in areas struck hardest by the shortage he is promising 
to “bring the water back.”

Experts cite climate change, wasteful irrigation practices and the 
depletion of groundwater supplies as leading factors in the growing 
water shortage. In the case of Lake Urmia, they add the completion of a 
series of dams that choked off a major supply of fresh water flowing 
from the mountains that tower on either side of the lake.

“Only some years ago the water here was 30 feet deep,” Mr. Ranaghadr 
said, kicking up dust with each step on the dry lake bed. In the 
distance, spots of land — once islands where tourists would spend 
vacations in bungalows overlooking the blue waters — were surrounded by 
plains of brown mud and sand. “We just emptied it out,” he said with a 
sigh, stepping back into the car.

Iran’s water troubles extend far beyond Lake Urmia, which as a salt lake 
was never fit for drinking or agricultural use. Other lakes and major 
rivers have also been drying up, leading to disputes over water rights, 
demonstrations and even riots.

Major rivers near Isfahan, in central Iran, and Ahvaz, near the Persian 
Gulf, have gone dry, as has Hamoun Lake, in the Afghanistan border 
region. Dust from the dry riverbeds has added to already dangerously 
high air pollution levels in Iran, home to four of the 10 most polluted 
cities in the world, the United Nations says.

But nowhere is the crisis more pronounced than at Lake Urmia, once one 
of the largest salt lakes in the world — at 90 miles long and roughly 35 
miles wide, it was slightly larger than Great Salt Lake in Utah. 
Environmentalists are warning that the dried salt could poison valuable 
agricultural lands surrounding the lake, and make life miserable for the 
three million people who live in its vicinity.

Along what used to be a lakeshore boulevard, worn-down snack bars and 
dressing rooms are testament to the days when people from across Iran 
would come to water-ski on the lake or cover themselves in its black 
mud, which is said to have healing powers.

About two decades ago, a local villager, Mokhtar Cheraghi, began to 
notice the water line receding. “First a hundred meters, then two 
hundred meters. After a while, we couldn’t see the shoreline anymore,” 
he said, standing in what was once his thriving cafe, Cheraghi’s Beach. 
“We kept waiting for the water to return, but it never did.”

Most people in the area blame the half-dozen major dams the government 
has built in the region for the lake’s disappearance. The dams have 
greatly reduced the flow of water in the 11 rivers that feed into the 
lake. As an arid country with numerous lofty mountain chains, Iran has a 
predilection for dams that extends to the reign of Shah Mohammed Reza 

Dam construction was given renewed emphasis under Mr. Rouhani’s 
predecessor as president, Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, who as an engineer had a 
weakness for grand projects. Another driving force is the Islamic 
Revolutionary Guards Corps, which through its engineering arm, Khatam 
al-Anbia Construction, builds many of the dams in Iran and surrounding 

Half an hour’s drive into the mountains above the city of Urmia stands 
the mighty Chahchai Dam, collecting water that would otherwise have 
reached the lake. The dam, finished during Mr. Ahmadinejad’s first term, 
now holds a huge lake itself, which local farmers use for irrigating 
their lands.

“Some of Urmia’s water is here,” said Mr. Ranaghadr, raising his voice 
over the howling winds that blow down from the surrounding snowcapped 
peaks. “The people here need water, too, is what they say.”

Besides producing badly needed electricity, the dams are intended to 
address the water shortage. But too often, the water is wasted through 
inefficient irrigation techniques, particularly spraying, Mr. Ranaghadr 
and other experts say.

In recent decades, the amount of land dedicated to agriculture in the 
region, the country’s heartland, has tripled, with many farmers growing 
particularly thirsty crops like grapes and sugar beets, Mr. Ranaghadr 
pointed out. His department has calculated that about 90 percent of all 
the water that should end up in the lake is sprayed on fields.

In a 2005 book that he wrote on national security challenges for Iran, 
Mr. Rouhani estimated that 92 percent of Iran’s water is used for 
agriculture, compared with 80 percent in the United States (90 percent 
in some Western states).

“They turn open the tap, flood the land, without understanding that in 
our climate most of the water evaporates that way,” said Ali Reza Seyed 
Ghoreishi, a member of the local water management council. “We need to 
educate the farmers.”

The lake has also been attacked from underground. As part of the 
government’s drive to promote local agriculture, large landholdings were 
divided into smaller plots, and most of the new owners promptly dug new 
wells, soaking up much of the groundwater.
Recent Comments
1 minute ago

Peak fresh water and peak oil may be playing out simultaneously and it's 
a very dangerous situation. Note that just this week the largest...
1 minute ago

Remember the Mad Max movies? Remember the desolate setting, the 
bleakness, the violence about oil?Mad Max is no longer fiction and the...
4 minutes ago

It is pathetic how humans dither and refuse to face the reality that 
they will have to sharply curb their numbers if there is to be any...

     See All Comments
     Write a comment

“There are around 30,000 legally dug wells and an equal amount of 
illegal wells,” Mr. Seyed Ghoreishi said. “As the water is becoming 
less, they have to dig deeper and deeper.”

Climate change, particularly rising temperatures, has played a role. 
Average temperatures around Lake Urmia have risen by a little over 3 
degrees in the past decade, official statistics show.

A long drought in the region seems to have ended two years ago, with 
rainfall levels returning to normal. But the increased rainfall has not 
made up for the other factors that are draining the lake.

“We are all to blame,” Mr. Ranaghadr said. “There are just too many 
people nowadays, and everybody needs to use the water and the 
electricity the dams generate.”

Back in his office, the Department of Environment, officials sounded 
like soldiers on a doomed mission. They had drawn up no fewer than 19 
plans to save the lake, ranging from the sensible (educating farmers in 
new irrigation technologies) to the fanciful (seeding clouds to increase 

“We can start now,” said Abbas Hassanpour, the head of the office. 
Flanked by his assistants, including Mr. Ranaghadr, he said his 
department had created “task forces and models ready to implement.”

While Iran is shooting monkeys into space to advance its missile 
program, the Rouhani government, low on funds because of the impact of 
the international sanctions against Iran’s nuclear program, has not made 
any money available for efforts to restore the lake.

Even if it were, officials say, it is probably too late to save Lake 
Urmia. All the money in the world can be poured into the lake, one of 
the officials said, but in the most optimistic projections, it would 
take decades, if ever, for the water to reach its old levels. There are 
simply too many problems, too many competing interests, for the rescue 
to be feasible.

Not doing anything, or not enough, will still create many problems. In 
2010 and 2011, violent protests over the lake erupted in Urmia, and 
security forces had to be flown in to restore order.

“We are not allowed to speak of the lake,” said Morteza Mirzaei, who 
lives in Urmia. “But they built their dams, and now everything is gone.” 
Others said ordinary people were also to blame, but “the government is 
the steward of the country,” said Mushin Rad, who sells printer 
equipment. “They are responsible.”

Mr. Ranaghadr, who grew up around the lake, said he spends free time 
battling poachers in the hills around it. “You know what the real 
problem is?” he said. “Everybody across the world is only thinking of 
money. We did, too, and now our lake is gone.”

More information about the Marxism mailing list