[Marxism] Kargalitsky analysis

Louis Proyect lnp3 at panix.com
Mon Jun 9 06:44:09 MDT 2014


What an odd presentation he gave to a pro-separatist gathering in 
Britain. He claims that the real conflict is not cultural but economic. 
I expected him naturally to discuss the oligarchy but instead his 
analysis centered on a Western "upper middle-class" in alliance with 
"marginal" elements (not sure what that meant, unemployed? street 
peddlers? farmers?) seeking to siphon off the "wealth" of the east, 
which generates 60 to 80 percent of the nation's GDP. This of course is 
in line with his analysis of Russian society in which the protests 
against Putin were a devious "upper middle-class" movement he held in 
contempt. This is of course similar to the analysis I heard from some 
about the Green movement in Iran that pitted effete, chablis-drinking 
snobs against the honest, hard-working proles who drank tea and prayed 3 
times a day. What this has to do with Marxism is anybody's guess.

More information about the Marxism mailing list