[Marxism] (no subject)

Andrew Pollack acpollack2 at gmail.com
Mon May 5 07:35:12 MDT 2014

This is the best reporting and analysis I've seen yet on this incident. I
have been unpleasantly surprised at how quickly some of my friends rushed
to share the most common account, which portrays those inside the building
as innocent bystanders or at most peaceful protesters, leaving out entirely
their role in the violent battles. Which, as the AWU statement makes clear,
is context, but not an excuse for their deaths.
Please use the link at the bottom of Sergii's post and share the statement.

On Mon, May 5, 2014 at 8:56 AM, Sergii Kutnii <mnkutster at gmail.com> wrote:

> ======================================================================
> Rule #1: YOU MUST clip all extraneous text when replying to a message.
> ======================================================================
> More than 40 people were killed and nearly 200 were wounded in the
> tragic clash of right-wing combatants in Odessa on May 2: football
> hooligans and Euromaidan self-defence on the one side; Stalinists,
> pro-Russian paramilitaries and local police force on the other.
> It started as a belligerent mob, comprised of men with “St. George’s
> ribbons” and red armbands (such armbands were also spotted on some
> police officers), wielding clubs and firearms, approached the march
> “for united Ukraine” which was made up of right-wing football
> hooligans joined by a large crowd of civilian people. As fighting
> began between the sides, the riot police provided cover to the
> attackers and cooperated with them. 4 people were killed. It is
> noteworthy that in the previous days the Antimaidan protesters had
> repeatedly marched along the centre of Odessa and never met any
> physical counteraction either from their political opponents or the
> police.
> Civilian “pro-Ukrainian” crowd didn’t disperse after the shootings;
> enraged, they started the counterattack. As the fighting became
> sufficiently intense, some of pro-Russian combatants withdrew to the
> Afina trading center, which was then blocked by the police. The crowd,
> incited by hooligans, followed the other part of the attackers and
> proceeded to rout the Antimaidan camp, located near the Trade Union
> house. The Antimaidan protesters fled to that building and then the
> entrances were barricaded. It should also be noted that Alexey Albu,
> leader of Stalinist Borotba organization, personally urged protesters
> to come inside the blocked building, although never joined them
> himself. We see this as a proof enough to any left or anarchist
> organization in the world to sever any ties, either financial or
> informational, with this organization. By sending them money you would
> fund the civil war; by spreading their statements and supporting them
> morally you would contribute to their war propaganda.
> Violence continued, as Euromaidan crowd surrounded the Trade Union
> house and combatants from both sides fired shots and hurled Molotov
> cocktails both to and fro the roof of the building. At this moment is
> still unclear which factor contributed the most to the fire, which
> burned some and suffocated others to death.
> We are sure that the violence of right-wing hooligans was the integral
> part of this tragedy. However, it is clear that this violence was
> planned for and counted on. The people who should also be held
> responsible are the pro-Russian instigators and the local police, who
> supported them.
> Members of AWU wish to express their deepest mourning for the victims.
> They fell prey to the interests of the forces that consistently try to
> instigate a civil war in Ukraine. Sadly, large parts of the working
> class are disoriented and serve as merely blind puppets in the hands
> of such forces, giving their lives for utterly stupid and meaningless
> things and ideas. The immediate effect of the escalation of this
> tragically pointless conflict is the split of the working class in
> Ukraine. While some workers are threatening with a political strike in
> support of the Antimaidan, several members of the (pro-Maidan)
> Confederation of Free Trade Unions are being kidnapped by Antimaidan
> forces. Instead of taking a united stance against the neoliberal
> policies of the government, proletarians are busy fighting each other
> for the interests of various bourgeois cliques.
> The final result of such policies will be a civil war in Ukraine,
> which will mean an ultimate catastrophe for the working class. We are
> not pacifists and will be at the side of the working class whenever it
> fights against the bourgeoisie, no matter what forms this fight takes
> — but this is not the case in Ukraine nowadays. The disoriented and
> weak proletariat will be busy engaging in self-destruction; the
> outcomes will be drastic fall of life standards, rise of unemployment
> and criminal activities, and loss of huge number of lives. All
> prospects of working-class self-organization and mobilization will be
> buried for some time.
> We can see that this scenario is being pushed forward by the alliance
> of various right-wing groups, nazis, conservatives and Stalinists. It
> is important to understand that Antimaidan cannot be considered a
> “working-class social protest”: the typical demands of this movement
> in various towns are dictated by the most reactionary clerical
> conservatives (abolition of electronic IDs because they include “the
> Number of the Beast”; banning of vaccination; etc.) and have little to
> do with the interests of workers.
> On the other hand, we are disgusted by the reaction of the
> right-liberal and patriotic general public which takes delight in the
> Odessa deaths. However wrong the killed people might have been, they
> shouldn’t have died in this brutish accident. As Ukrainian workers
> side with various warring right-wing movements, they are sliding
> further from socialism to barbarism. The cure is well-known: we should
> realize our own class interests, organize at workplaces and direct our
> rage against the real enemy, not at each other. In days like these
> global workers’ solidarity means very much. The global working class
> is doomed to eliminate itself: either in the process of social
> revolution and construction of a classless society or in the process
> of a barbaric all-out war.
> No gods, no masters, no nations, no borders!
> Autonomous Workers’ Union – Kiev
> 5 May 2014
> http://avtonomia.net/2014/05/05/awu-kiev-statement-odessa-tragedy/
> ________________________________________________
> Send list submissions to: Marxism at greenhouse.economics.utah.edu
> Set your options at:
> http://greenhouse.economics.utah.edu/mailman/options/marxism/acpollack2%40gmail.com

More information about the Marxism mailing list