[Marxism] Crisis in France Is Seen as Sign of Chronic Ills

Louis Proyect lnp3 at panix.com
Thu Jan 15 06:45:16 MST 2015

NY Times, Jan.15 2015
Crisis in France Is Seen as Sign of Chronic Ills

VAULX-EN-VELIN, France — France may have just hosted its biggest 
outpouring of solidarity since the end of World War II in response to 
the terrorist attacks last week in and around Paris that left 17 dead at 
the satirical newspaper Charlie Hebdo and a kosher supermarket.

But in the disaffected suburbs, or banlieues, that ring France’s largest 
cities, those appeals for unity hardly penetrated the sense of 
isolation, even siege, that has left cities like this one living a 
parallel existence from the rest of the country.

“I am French, and I feel French,” said Nabil Souidi, 23. “But here you 
are forbidden to say, ‘I am Charlie,’ ” referring to the rallying cry of 
solidarity since the attack on the magazine.

Mr. Souidi recently graduated from a trade school and hoped to find a 
job as a mechanic. Months later, he is still out of work, searching for 
a Plan B. “I’ll go to Syria,” he said, with a sarcastic laugh in an 
interview over a plate of French fries and mayonnaise.

For him and many other French Muslims, the nation’s preoccupation with 
last week’s attacks at the hands of Islamic extremists presents a mere 
distraction from a fundamental social crisis that has plagued France’s 
immigrant neighborhoods for decades.

In numerous interviews, community leaders and Muslims and North Africans 
who largely populate the banlieues expressed concern that last week’s 
attacks in Paris would intensify an already explosive social and 
economic situation in the places where they live.

On Tuesday, a French association that represents 120 mayors across 
France issued a statement warning that the banlieues were “on edge” amid 
the fallout from the attacks, and said there was an urgent need to 
address economic, social and educational shortfalls.

Vaulx-en-Velin, a dreary Muslim-majority suburb of Lyon, is France’s 
third-poorest city and representative of the problems. Many youths 
simply call it “a ghetto.” It might also be called the Other France.

Here, and in numerous other poor suburbs that ring French cities, 
joblessness runs around 20 percent, about double the national average. 
For young people, it can be as high as 40 percent. About half of 
residents do not have a high school diploma. Police harassment and 
profiling are taken for granted as the rule.

In a time of budget cuts and austerity, conditions have only 
deteriorated despite years of pledges by successive governments, 
including President François Hollande’s, to improve schools and create 

The men who carried out the attacks — Saïd Kouachi and his brother 
Chérif, and Amedy Coulibaly, who seized the kosher market — grew up in 
the French banlieues and had failed to hold down a series of menial jobs 
in their youth.

All were attracted to Islamic extremism by their teenage years, and many 
residents in the banlieues consider them bad seeds who were propelled 
toward the fringe.

Yet the fallout from their attacks, and the response shown by the rest 
of France, has been Topic A along the gritty streets of many 
impoverished suburbs from Paris down through the south of France.

Many worried that as Muslims, they would be lumped together with the 
killers. Others spoke of fears of retaliation against mosques and other 
Muslim symbols, as well as the specter of reprisals or even a crackdown 
by the police after officers were murdered in the terrorist attacks.

“People feel like there is no solution — that they are just totally 
divided from the rest of society,” said Gounedi Traore, 37, a social 
worker at the Centre Social Intercommunal de la Dhuys, a community 
center in Clichy-sous-Bois, a suburb outside of Paris that is one of 
France’s most economically deprived. “After what happened with Charlie 
Hebdo, I feel that this is going to set off a war.”

Nearly everyone agreed that the fallout from the Charlie Hebdo attacks, 
including a heightened security response by France and its allies, was a 
distraction from a larger problem: a sense of increasing social and 
economic marginalization that many cited as a root cause of young people 
drifting toward extremism.

“The attacks had a global impact but not local impact,” said Faouzi 
Hamdi, rector of the Okba Ibn Nafee Mosque in Vaulx-en-Velin.

Community leaders say France’s drawn-out economic crisis has made 
already scarce job opportunities even worse.

“We are not treating the problem at its roots,” said Leila Legmara, a 
deputy mayor for education in the Paris suburb of Colombes. “Of course 
we need more security and resources to fight terrorism. But we also need 
to address what it is within our society that is capable of producing 

The sense of marginalization did not disappear with the massive 
solidarity march across Paris on Sunday, which drew more than one 
million people and 40 presidents and prime ministers to Mr. Hollande’s 
side. For some banlieue residents, it seemed an almost surreal display 
that had nothing to do with them.

In Vaulx-en-Velin, the only Charlie reference to be seen was a sign for 
the Charlie Chaplin cultural center across the street from City Hall, 
which is topped with a drawing of a flag of its sister city, the West 
Bank town of Beit Sahour.

Residents there ridiculed the “I am Charlie” marches. Some said the 
terrorist attacks had been staged. While many strongly condemned the 
attackers for the murders, others insisted the cartoonists had gotten 
what they deserved.

Local leaders say this city of 44,000 is a microcosm of France’s failed 
integration policy, and the underlying social problems that have 
encouraged young people toward radicalization. Places like 
Vaulx-en-Velin have remained “priority zones” for the government since 
1964, some noted.

As in Clichy-sous-Bois, youth here said they felt as if they were living 
in a separate country, detached from the social and economic benefits of 
the state and abandoned by a system that preaches unity and solidarity 
with France’s republican secular values.

“I totally feel cut off from France,” said Karim Yahiaoui, 15, who added 
that he had not left this suburb more than twice in the past year. Over 
the past few decades, the Muslim community in Vaulx-en-Velin has become 
increasingly insular. “Many people only believe their own values now, 
not those of the republic,” said Anne Dufaud, director of the Mission, a 
nonprofit organization. She has worked in the community for 20 years. 
When Mr. Hollande led a moment of silence across France last Thursday 
for the victims of the attacks, two students and a teacher at a local 
high school, who declined to be identified, said many students refused 
to stand.

Patrick Kahn, a manager at the International League Against Racism and 
Anti-Semitism in Lyon, who operates a weekly tolerance program in the 
schools of Vaulx-en-Velin, said simply, “The integration policy failed.”

“The suburbs were left behind in government planning, so they became 
segregated communities,” he explained. Fear of the authorities was 
already omnipresent, reflected in crude antipolice graffiti on many of 
the concrete housing complexes, which residents call “les cages de 
poulet,” or chicken coops.

The attacks only deepened concerns about racial profiling — already a 
common occurrence. One woman wearing an abaya said she had left the 
house only twice since the Charlie Hebdo attacks because she was afraid 
of the authorities.

Inside schools, students said there were already deep social divisions 
between Muslims and non-Muslims. One community leader said it was 
impossible to open a discussion about the Charlie Hebdo attacks without 
first explaining what satire, caricatures and freedom of expression 
were. Several teachers said their attempts to discuss the events had led 
to tense exchanges.

“Schools reflect the society,” said Stéphane Gomez, general councilor 
and deputy mayor of Vaulx-en-Velin. Mr. Gomez is also a high school 
teacher in the region. “We have to talk about what has gone wrong and 
reopen the debates that we’ve been afraid to talk about for so long,” he 

In Clichy-sous-Bois, residents said such a debate would have to include 
a hard look at the economic and social segregation that has defined 
France’s banlieues decade after decade.

“We need to give people ways to succeed,” said Mohamed Mokkadem, 37, who 
runs a trucking company, SKL Transports.

Mr. Mokkadem had tried, to no avail, to buy a copy of the latest Charlie 
Hebdo that hit newsstands on Wednesday. He said he was curious to see 
close-up the new depiction of the Prophet Muhammad on the cover.

Conditions were already bleak in his neighborhood even before the 
killings, he said, and now, more than ever, he wanted to send a pointed 
message to the government and the country.

“What we are asking for is to be respected according to our worth,” he 
said. “The message, quite simply, is to be regarded as truly French.”

Adam B. Ellick reported from Vaulx-en-Velin, and Liz Alderman from 
Clichy-sous-Bois. Yann Cress contributed reporting from 
Clichy-sous-Bois, and Lisa Burek from Vaulx-en-Velin.

More information about the Marxism mailing list