[Marxism] Despair and Anger as Puerto Ricans Cope With Debt Crisis
lnp3 at panix.com
Sat Jul 4 09:04:36 MDT 2015
(The parallels with Greece are palpable. If a colony of the USA that was
held up as a showcase alternative to Cuba is such a basket case, what
does that say about the failure of capitalism to deliver the goods?)
NY Times, July 4 2015
Despair and Anger as Puerto Ricans Cope With Debt Crisis
By LIZETTE ALVAREZ
SAN JUAN, P.R. — It’s the lunch hour at Baker’s Bakery, a fixture in Río
Piedras, one of Puerto Rico’s oldest neighborhoods, but the bustle at
the counter is long gone. The front door opens and shuts only a few
times an hour as customers, holding tighter than ever to their money,
judiciously pick up some sugar-sprinkled pastries and a café con leche.
On the first day of the new sales tax, which jumped to 11.5 percent from
7 percent, the government’s latest rummage for more revenue, Puerto
Rico’s malaise was unmistakable.
“People don’t even answer you when you tell them, ‘Buenos dias,’ ” said
Ibrahim Baker, 55, on Wednesday as he stood at the cash register of the
bakery he has owned for 25 years. “Everyone is depressed.”
After nearly a decade of recession, Puerto Rico’s government says it
cannot pay its $73 billion debt much longer. Gov. Alejandro García
Padilla warns that more austerity is on the way, a necessity for an
island now working feverishly to rescue itself. With so many bracing for
another slide toward the bottom, the sense of despair grows more
palpable by the day.
“So many people are leaving you can’t even find suitcases,” said Erica
Lebrón, 30, as she sat outside a housing project bodega.
Before long, Puerto Ricans will face more tax increases — the next one
is in October. Next on the list of anticipated measures, these for
government workers, are fewer vacations, overtime hours and paid sick
days. Others in Puerto Rico may face cuts in health care benefits and
even bus routes, all changes that economic advisers say should be made
to jump-start the economy.
People ricochet from anger to resignation back to anger again. Along San
Juan’s colonial-era streets, in homes and shops, Puerto Ricans blame the
government for the economic debacle. Election after election, they say,
political leaders took the easy way out, spending more than they had,
borrowing to prop up the budget, pointing fingers at one another and
failing to own up to reality.
“It’s very, very, very worrisome,” said Mr. Baker, who added that he
wanted the federal government to oversee the rescue plan because “in the
hands of Puerto Rico’s politicians, this will never get better.”
For Mr. Baker, each year has been worse than the one before. He first
opened his business here 25 years ago, not too far from the University
of Puerto Rico. At one time, 23 employees served up pasteles and tortas.
Now he has one worker, and his daughter, a recent college graduate who
cannot find a job, also works behind the counter. Sales have plummeted
50 percent and, over the years, he has been forced to close two other
Taxes continue to go up. But so do other costs. Living on an island,
many business owners must ship their goods in from a mainland port,
already a costly proposition. But a 1920 law, the Jones Act, which
requires Puerto Rico to receive its shipments from the United States on
American-built ships with mainly American crews, makes the cost of
transporting goods even more expensive. Recently, it got costlier, Mr.
Now there is a chorus of calls for Congress to relax the law as it
relates to Puerto Rico. And some powerful Democrats are rallying behind
the idea of granting Puerto Rico, a commonwealth, the ability to file
bankruptcy for some of its debt-laden agencies.
“I have to pass some of these costs on to customers,” Mr. Baker
lamented, a tray of bread at the ready and an espresso machine churning
in the background. For example, the price of ham, he said, recently
increased for him to $2.39 a pound from $1.19 a pound because of
shipping costs. “So we have fewer customers. Some months nothing is left
over for us after we have paid the bills.”
The high cost of electricity and water in Puerto Rico also make running
his bakery, and paying his bills at home, all the harder. “I am stuck
here because I have no alternatives,” he said. “I don’t have the
opportunity now to even try.”
Many others in Puerto Rico, including a stream of professionals and
middle-class workers, have sought alternatives. They have moved to the
mainland for jobs and better prospects. Over the past decade, Puerto
Rico has lost more than 5 percent of its population, which now numbers
3.6 million, according to a New York Federal Reserve report. An
additional 250,000 people are expected to leave by 2020, according to
the Puerto Rico Planning Board.
This year, the government closed dozens of schools across the island.
About 40 percent of the island’s municipalities now have more old people
than children, which means fewer workers in the pipeline and a greater
need for benefits like Medicare.
A few blocks from the bakery, Paseo de Diego, a pedestrian corridor once
buzzing with shops and shoppers, sits nearly empty. Store after store
has closed, their metal grates covered in graffiti, except for a stretch
near a busy market.
With his hats for sale on a display on the grates of a closed store
along the Paseo, José Vasquez Torres, 67, said business was more than
slow. “I’ve been here since 6 a.m. and not sold a single hat.”
Sitting on a folding chair next to the hats, his partner, María L.
Luyando Hernandez, 62, held a thick sheaf of papers. Even a business as
small and mobile as this one, she said, requires paperwork, payments and
“These are all the papers we have to fill out to sell hats here,” she
said. The couple owe $461 for the permit but they do not have the money.
Not too long ago, the cost of a permit, Ms. Luyando said, was $21. Some
sellers were able to take out loans at inexpensive interest rates to
keep their businesses going, but Mr. Vasquez said he did not qualify
because he had failed to pay his phone bill.
Despite a growing stack of unpaid bills, the couple manage to get by,
Ms. Luyando said, because they live in affordable Section 8 housing — a
small one-bedroom apartment nearby — and receive food stamps.
“We are behind,” she said, “we are always behind.”
Far more people use food stamps here — 35 percent — than on the United
States mainland, a reflection of Puerto Rico’s poverty rate of 41
percent, nearly double that of the poorest state, Mississippi. And about
60 percent are enrolled in Medicaid or some form of Medicare.
A health care crisis now looms. The federal government plans to cut
Medicare Advantage, a popular private program run with Medicare funds,
by 11 percent next year, a reduction that has already triggered rallies
Angel Ramon Rivera, 57, a friend of Mr. Vasquez, the hat seller,
recently received some training as a sound engineer and is working as a
D.J., charging small amounts because no one can afford more. Like many
in Puerto Rico, he is part of the underground economy, which makes it
easier for him to do business but harder for the government to collect
taxes. But the work is sporadic and he, too, collects food stamps. He is
saving his money to get out of Puerto Rico.
As he talks, his anger bubbles up. “They want us to pay for their
mistakes,” Mr. Rivera said, of the lawmakers. “This is not our fault.
And they shouldn’t raise taxes on the rich, either. It’s not their
fault. It’s the fault of the legislature.”
Mercedes Martinez, the new head of the Teachers Federation of Puerto
Rico, said the deepening crisis and calls for more austerity will once
again hit the working class.
“We all have to sacrifice but workers have already sacrificed too much,”
she said of the sales tax, layoffs and pension cuts. “We are not willing
to make one more sacrifice. The ones who need to sacrifice are the
people who created this.”
“We will throw ourselves into the streets, if we have to,” she added.
Leaning against a lamppost near the Paseo, his measuring tape around his
neck, Porfirio Guerrero, 61, said he feels drained.
Sastrería Pachín, the tailor shop he owns, used to offer him a good
life. Now he lists his troubles in numbers: His water bill, made worse
by a drought here, has gone up to $64 a month from $21, and he barely
uses water. Thirty stores on his street have closed in the past 10 years
or so. It is 11:30 a.m. and not one customer has stopped in.
“Before, I went to the movies, I drank some beers with friends,” he
said. “Now I go from the business to my home. That’s it. It’s suffocating.”
He arrived here from the Dominican Republic 28 years ago — “a lifetime
ago” — and worked hard to build a life. He succeeded, against hard odds,
not always easy for Dominicans, who sometimes face discrimination here.
“I guess the government thinks that because we have jobs, we are fine,”
Mr. Guerrero said. It’s not that simple, he added, gesturing toward the
empty street. “I just look down there and want to cry. We feel like we
are a forgotten people in a forgotten land.”
More information about the Marxism