[Marxism] Nada Elia: Time to Stop Celebrating Jewish Dissent in Palestine Solidarity Mvmt

Louis Proyect lnp3 at panix.com
Fri Apr 29 08:24:30 MDT 2016

On 4/29/16 10:07 AM, DW via Marxism wrote:
> Weir, besides have zero understanding of Imperialism as a class, is notable
> because she refuses to take up blatant anti-Jewish bigotry when it's thrown
> in her face on the many right-wing, tea-party like radio stations she
> appears on. Some of these broadcasts are on YouTube or on those networks
> steaming audio. She simply sits there and avoids confronting such bigotry.
> Among many Palestinian solidarity activists, this is unforgivable.

A lot of these problems are rooted in the crisis of Marxism. When I 
joined the SWP in 1967, the axis of Palestinian solidarity was in the 
overlapping spheres of radical nationalism and Marxism. Palestinian 
guerrillas identified with Che Guevara and the Trotskyist movement 
worldwide was capable of rallying people around class-based slogans and 
analysis. People like Peter Buch and Jon Rothschild used to speak to 
thousands of people on campuses around the country. In 1973 I organized 
a Militant Forum on the Yom Kippur war in Houston that drew 125 people, 
including just about every radical Arab student in the area as well as 
the local TV station.

So what happened? The left imploded. The USSR went kaput. The 
Palestinian solidarity movement on campus emerged around BDS but with 
little involvement from Marxists. You also had a development of 
"realists" opposed to Zionism like Mearsheimer and Walt, as well as 
liberals fed up with the settlers. You also had Hamas that screwed 
things up with suicide bombing. A complete mess for the most part.

In my opinion Allison Weir is a person whose views are shaped by the 
general milieu, one that is not favorable to a class analysis. In the 
1970s she would have barely gotten attention. We need to change the 
objective circumstances in order to promote a POV that can serve the 
Palestinian cause more effectively. That unfortunately can not be done 

More information about the Marxism mailing list