[Marxism] Saudi Court Spares Poet’s Life but Gives Him 8 Years and 800 Lashes

Louis Proyect lnp3 at panix.com
Wed Feb 3 08:36:50 MST 2016

NY Times, Feb. 3 2016
Saudi Court Spares Poet’s Life but Gives Him 8 Years and 800 Lashes

RIYADH, Saudi Arabia — A court in Saudi Arabia on Tuesday revised the 
punishment given to a stateless Palestinian poet convicted of apostasy, 
reducing it from death to eight years in prison, 800 lashes and public 
repentance, his lawyer said.

The poet, Ashraf Fayadh, had been sentenced to beheading because of the 
apostasy conviction announced in November, based partly on his published 

The sentence stirred outrage among international artists and human 
rights groups at a time when Saudi officials were seeking to rebut 
comparisons between their application of Sharia law and the practices of 
the Islamic State extremist group.

The sentence also came near the end of a year in which the Saudi 
authorities carried out the highest number of executions here in two 
decades, and just before a mass execution of 47 men on terrorism 
charges, including a Shiite cleric who had called for the downfall of 
the royal family.

Mr. Fayadh, 35, was not a known dissident. He was born in Saudi Arabia 
to a stateless family of Palestinian origin, meaning that has no 
citizenship; he carries identification documents issued by Egypt.

He was active in Saudi Arabia’s small contemporary arts scene and had 
worked to make it better known. He curated shows at home and abroad, and 
in 2013 was interviewed on a Saudi television station about an 
exhibition he had organized in the Saudi city of Jiddah called Mostly 

His legal troubles began when he was arrested in 2013 in the city of 
Abha in southwestern Saudi Arabia after an argument in a cafe. He was 
released without charge, but rearrested later and accused of blasphemy 
and illicit relationships with women. The charges were based on 
photographs and the contents of his poetry book published abroad years 
before, according to court documents.

He was found guilty and sentenced to four years in prison and 800 blows. 
But that sentence was thrown out on appeal, and Mr. Fayadh was retried 
and sentenced to death.

While some Saudi officials have said privately that the sentence was too 
harsh, the kingdom’s judiciary is controlled by deeply conservative 
clerics who have great latitude to define crimes and issue punishments 
they deem appropriate.

Saudi courts have given similarly harsh sentences to those they see as a 
threat to the religious nature of the state. In 2014, they sentenced 
Raef Badawi, a liberal blogger who had criticized the religious 
establishment, to 10 years in prison, a large fine and 1,000 blows, to 
be delivered in multiple floggings. The public administration of the 
first 50 blows last year caused international condemnation, and Mr. 
Badawi has not been publicly caned since, although he remains in prison.

Mr. Fayadh’s lawyer, Abdulrahman al-Lahim, appealed the case, and the 
court announced the new sentence on Tuesday, according to a statement 
Mr. Lahim posted on his Twitter account.

The statement said the judges still considered Mr. Fayadh guilty but had 
withdrawn the death penalty, sentencing him instead to eight years in 
prison and 800 blows, to be administered 50 at a time. Mr. Fayadh would 
also have to publicly denounce his writings in official Saudi news 
media, the statement said.

Mr. Lahim said he would file a new appeal.

Saudi officials have not commented on Mr. Fayadh’s case, and they did 
not respond to requests for comment.

“From our perspective, this shouldn’t even be a case,” said Adam Coogle, 
a researcher at Human Rights Watch.

“You have gotten rid of the death penalty, which I guess is good, but 
eight years and 800 blows is a ludicrous price to pay for a speech 
crime,” he said.

PEN America, a press-freedom advocacy group that had publicized Mr. 
Fayadh’s conviction and punishment, also had a mixed reaction.

“Our relief that Ashraf no longer faces beheading is diminished by the 
extended injustice and mercilessness of the new sentence dealt to him 
for the simple human act of artistic expression,” said Karin Deutsch 
Karlekar, the director of Free Expression Programs at PEN America. 
“Words do not constitute crimes.”

More information about the Marxism mailing list