[Marxism] Many in Milwaukee Neighborhood Didn’t Vote — and Don’t Regret It
lnp3 at panix.com
Mon Nov 21 14:02:49 MST 2016
(Actually, a more accurate title for the article would be "Many Blacks
in Milwaukee Neighborhood Didn’t Vote — and Don’t Regret It".)
NY Times, Nov. 21 2016
Many in Milwaukee Neighborhood Didn’t Vote — and Don’t Regret It
By SABRINA TAVERNISE
MILWAUKEE — Four barbers and a firefighter were pondering their future
under a Trump presidency at the Upper Cutz barbershop last week.
“We got to figure this out,” said Cedric Fleming, one of the barbers.
“We got a gangster in the chair now,” he said, referring to
President-elect Donald J. Trump.
They admitted that they could not complain too much: Only two of them
had voted. But there were no regrets.
“I don’t feel bad,” Mr. Fleming said, trimming a mustache. “Milwaukee is
tired. Both of them were terrible. They never do anything for us anyway.”
As Democrats pick through the wreckage of the campaign, one lesson is
clear: The election was notable as much for the people who did not show
up, as for those who did. Nationally, about half of registered voters
did not cast ballots.
Wisconsin, a state that Hillary Clinton had assumed she would win,
historically boasts one of the nation’s highest rates of voter
participation; this year’s 68.3 percent turnout was the fifth best among
the 50 states. But by local standards, it was a disappointment, the
lowest turnout in 16 years. And those no-shows were important. Mr. Trump
won the state by just 27,000 voters.
Milwaukee’s lowest-income neighborhoods offer one explanation for the
turnout figures. Of the city’s 15 council districts, the decline in
turnout from 2012 to 2016 in the five poorest was consistently much
greater than the drop seen in more prosperous areas — accounting for
half of the overall decline in turnout citywide.
The biggest drop was here in District 15, a stretch of fading wooden
homes, sandwich shops and fast-food restaurants that is 84 percent
black. In this district, voter turnout declined by 19.5 percent from
2012 figures, according to Neil Albrecht, executive director of the City
of Milwaukee Election Commission. It is home to some of Milwaukee’s
poorest residents and, according to a 2016 documentary, “Milwaukee
53206,” has one of the nation’s highest per-capita incarceration rates.
At Upper Cutz, a bustling barbershop in a green-trimmed wooden house,
talk of politics inevitably comes back to one man: Barack Obama. Mr.
Obama’s elections infused many here with a feeling of connection to
national politics they had never before experienced. But their lives
have not gotten appreciably better, and sourness has set in.
“We went to the beach,” said Maanaan Sabir, 38, owner of the Juice
Kitchen, a brightly painted shop a few blocks down West North Avenue,
using a metaphor to describe the emotion after Mr. Obama’s election.
“And then eight years happened.”
All four barbers had voted for Mr. Obama. But only two could muster the
enthusiasm to vote this time. And even then, it was a sort of protest.
One wrote in Mrs. Clinton’s Democratic opponent, Senator Bernie Sanders
of Vermont. The other wrote in himself.
“I’m so numb,” said Jahn Toney, 45, who had written in Mr. Sanders. He
said no president in his lifetime had done anything to improve the lives
of black people, including Mr. Obama, whom he voted for twice. “It’s
like I should have known this would happen. We’re worse off than before.”
But Mr. Obama did do something important: “He did give black people
something to aspire to. That’s a lot. I’m happy my son was able to see a
Mr. Fleming, 47, who has been trimming hair, beards and mustaches for 30
years, had hoped his small business would get easier to run. But it hasn’t.
“Give us loans, or a 401(k),” he said, trimming the mustache of Steve
Stricklin, a firefighter from the neighborhood. His biggest issue was
health insurance. Mr. Fleming lost his coverage after his divorce three
years ago and has struggled to find a policy he could afford. He finally
found one, which starts Monday but costs too much at $300 a month.
“Ain’t none of this been working,” he said. He did not vote.
Mr. Albrecht, of the election commission, said other factors contributed
to the decline in turnout. This was the first general election under new
state laws that required voters to produce an approved photo ID card,
and that stiffened the requirements for new voters to prove their
residence. This was particularly onerous for the poor, who move often.
Mr. Albrecht said he believed this change had cost several thousand
people in the city their vote.
“To me that’s very significant,” he said. “It takes away from the
fairness and integrity of the election.”
Although two federal district courts had ruled that the photo ID law
discriminated against African-Americans, who disproportionately lack the
approved IDs, the law was applied on Election Day after an appeals court
stayed one of the decisions. Gov. Scott Walker, a Republican who backed
the laws, has said they have no impact on voter participation, and Mr.
Albrecht allowed that their effect on Milwaukee’s turnout would not have
erased Mr. Trump’s victory in the state.
Perhaps the biggest drags on voter turnout in Milwaukee, as in the rest
of the country, were the candidates themselves. To some, it was like
having to choose between broccoli and liver.
“I felt cornered,” said Ian Pfeiffer, 25, who works the grill at Jake’s
Delicatessen and says he did not vote. “We were stuck between Trump and
Hillary. They really left us with no choice.”
Mr. Pfeiffer’s grandmother, an avid supporter of Mrs. Clinton, spent
months trying to convince him to vote for her. But he could not get over
his revulsion at what he saw as trust issues related to the Clinton
Foundation. (Mr. Pfeiffer’s grandfather pushed him toward Mr. Trump, but
he found him even less appealing.)
He thought Oprah Winfrey would be a good candidate.
“Hey, would you vote for Oprah Winfrey?” he said in a loud voice to a
line of customers.
“Yeah, I’d vote for her,” said Erin Miles, 41, a financial services
worker waiting for her sandwich. “She has a level head and
Few of the men and women interviewed on West North Street last week had
voted for Mr. Trump, though many said they admired him. (He spoke his
mind. He was rich.)
“If I would have voted, I would have voted for him,” said Andre
Frierson, 40, a security guard working the evening shift at Jake’s.
“From a business perspective, I loved him.”
As for Mrs. Clinton, “other countries probably wouldn’t have respected
us because we had a woman running the country,” he said.
One exception was Justin Babar, who said he voted for Mr. Trump as a
protest against Mrs. Clinton. He blamed her husband’s policies for
putting him in prison for 20 years.
As for the claims of racism that have dogged Mr. Trump, Mr. Babar wasn’t
so worried. “It’s better than smiling to my face but going behind closed
doors and voting against our kids,” he said.
Tarvus Hawthorne, 45, a program coordinator at a local nonprofit, agreed.
“He was real, unlike a lot of liberal Democrats who are just as racist”
but keep it hidden, he said, his jaw slathered with shaving cream. “You
can reason with them all day long, but they think they know it all. They
want to have control. That they know what’s best for ‘those people.’”
Still, he voted for Mrs. Clinton, as did many others here.
Upper Cutz gets busier as the day wears on. Children come in after
school. Danielle Rogers, Mr. Toney’s sister, stopped by the barbershop
for a visit. Everybody agreed they would miss Mr. Obama.
Ms. Rogers said Mr. Obama had aged a lot. “It’s like having a bunch of
bad kids,” she said. “He’s probably saying: ‘I’m done. Take them back to
their mama’s house.’”
Mr. Fleming was trying to imagine Mr. Trump as president.
“The White House is going to be the penthouse!” he said, adding that Mr.
Trump would be like Al Pacino in “Scarface,” with parties in the mansion
and exotic animals roaming around the grounds. “If he comes home and
finds his wife cheating on him, he could just say, ‘Let’s go to war!’”
They were laughing. But they were also worried.
“He’s going to mess with us on some racist level,” said Otis Jackson,
45, a barber who did not vote. “He’s already appointed a known racist,”
he said, referring to Stephen K. Bannon, Mr. Trump’s chief strategist
and the former head of Breitbart News, which has been denounced as a
white nationalist hate site.
With so many people sitting in his chair over the years, Mr. Fleming has
developed a keen sense of where society is headed. But now he is stumped.
“This was a weird election,” he said, holding a set of clippers and
looking pensive. “You can’t tell what’s on people’s minds. There are
less cars out there. No one wants to come out. No one knows what comes
He added, “Hell, Trump doesn’t even know.”
More information about the Marxism