[Marxism] People's Forum on BRICS

Louis Proyect lnp3 at panix.com
Fri Oct 14 07:48:48 MDT 2016

Press Release


People's Forum on BRICS held in Goa develops a declaration for heads of 
state attending the 8th BRICS Summit

GOA, 14 October 2016: The People's Forum on BRICS that took place in Goa 
on the 13th and 14th of Goa witnessed several social movements and civil 
society formations, representing the people of at least 10 countries, 
make a declaration towards the official 8th BRICS summit in Goa.

The declaration has urged upon the BRICS nations to look at issues of 
Social, Economic and Environmental justice and has reminded the BRICS 
leadership of a time of an unprecedented crisis facing humanity and nature.

The forum has emphasised the threat that several democracies across the 
world are facing from reactionary and imperialist forces and has in 
particular drawn attention to the coup in Brazil that has overthrown a 
people's government.  The representatives also noticed with great 
concern the state repression of people's movements and student’s 
protests in countries including India and South Africa.

The declaration also points out the massive levels of ecological 
destruction that is taking place around the world, led by corporations 
and in collusion with the state.  Goa, the site of the summit is 
ironically at the receiving end of this destruction.

The Forum also pointed out the teetering world economy that is on the 
verge of another financial meltdown resulting in stocks and currency 
market crisis in many of the BRICS countries. The longer-term crisis of 
capitalism is evident in the marked slowdown in international trade, in 
declining global profit rates, and in business disinvestment, especially 
evident in the three BRICS which have negative or negligible GDP growth.

The world’s workers are losing rights, farmers are suffering to the 
point of suicide, and labour casualisation is rampant in all our 
countries, with the result that BRICS workers are engaged in regular 
protest and wildcat strikes, of which the strike by 180 million Indian 
workers inspired the world on 2 September;

On the social front, the threat to our already-inadequate welfare 
policies is serious, especially in Brazil’s coup regime but more 
generally across the BRICS where inadequate social policies are not 
providing adequate safety nets;

The commodification of public services is causing misery, such as in 
South Africa where university students are fighting hard for a fee-free, 
decolonised tertiary education;

Everywhere that people’s movements have made countervailing demands – 
such as democracy, peace, poverty eradication, sustainable development, 
equality, fair trade – the elites have co-opted our language and 
distorted our visions beyond recognition. Many of our leaders are 
hopelessly corrupt, and so when BRICS spin-doctors claim that their work 
in Goa will “build responsive, inclusive and collective solutions,” we 
have spent two days looking beyond the pleasing rhetoric and have found 
a very different, harsh reality.

In short, whereas we criticise the way world power is created and 
exercised, the BRICS leaders appear to simply want power sharing. To 
illustrate, the BRICS New Development Bank is working hand-in-glove with 
the World Bank; the Contingent Reserve Arrangement empowers the 
International Monetary Fund; and the Asian Infrastructure Investment 
Bank serves mainly corporate interests – and all these financial 
institutions lack opportunities for adequate civil society monitoring 
and participation.

As a result, the Forum has raised constructive critiques of BRICS in our 
plenaries and workshops. But beyond the analysis, we understand that 
only people’s power, across borders, can make change. Some of our most 
successful struggles – such as access to life-savings medicines or 
ending apartheid – required international solidarity. This Forum found 
many routes forward for cross-cutting BRICS internationalism in various 

For example, the Forum recognises the need for a just solution to the 
Syrian crisis in accordance with the principles of international law, 
and condemns the US-backed aggression and the Pentagon/NATO doctrine of 
regime change. The Forum reaffirmed its solidarity with the Palestinian 
struggle against colonialism and occupation, and we endorse Boycotts, 
Divestment and Sanctions against apartheid Israel, including opposition 
to Israel’s attempted export of its unsustainable water and agricultural 
technologies to BRICS countries.
The social movements and progressive unions and formations who gathered 
at the Xavier’s Centre for Historical Research, Goa declared their 
intention to win their demands for social, economic and environmental 
justice. The victories that many of the movements  have won already on 
multiple fronts – such as halting numerous multinational corporations’ 
exploitation, gaining access to essential state services, occupying land 
and creating agricultural cooperatives,  and generating more humane 
values in our societies – give the Forum the  momentum and optimism. In 
2017 and beyond, the BRICS People’s Forum will reconvene, and redouble 
our efforts with new-found allies from Brazil, Russia, India, China and 
South Africa.

Peoplesforumonbrics at gmail.com


BRICS is fast turning into a free market ploy to loot natural resources: 
Medha Patkar
Abhilash / 19 hours ago

img_9827-001A two-day long People’s Forum on BRICS kick started today at 
the Xavier’s Centre for Historical Research, Alto Porvorim Goa.

The opening plenary, chaired by renowned women’s rights and 
environmentalist activist Norma Alvares, saw eminent social movement 
leaders from the BRICS region addressing a gathering of over five 
hundred people from at least 10 countries around the world.

Several speakers recounted and emphasised on the fact that BRICS was 
formed to challenge the imperialistic and hegemonic nature of 
institutions such as the World Bank and IMF. When the five countries of 
Brazil, Russia, India, China and South Africa came together to form 
BRICS, it was done with an intent to bring about social justice and 
equity in these countries that was home to over 50% of the world’s 

Yet, even as the governments of these nations come together for their 
8th Summit in Goa, it is a matter of serious concern that BRICS is 
following a path that is opposed to its foundational principles by 
increasingly aligning with capitalist and imperialists forces of the world.

Speaking in the opening plenary that deliberated on the CRISES THAT 
PEOPLE FACE – WHAT IS BRICS’ RESPONSE? – noted Indian activist Medha 
Patkar commented that BRICS has failed to challenge the hegemony of 
imperialist states. She accused that in all these countries, private 
corporations are increasingly taking control of democratic institutions 
and overriding people’s participation in crucial decision-making 
processes. BRICS has done little to advance social justice and equity in 
these countries. She reminded the audience that India, despite being the 
largest democracy in the world, is also a sight where the poorest and 
the most marginalized people are continuing their struggle for social 
justice, dignity and identity. People have been kept outside of the 
decisions that are taken on their behalf for their development she accused.

Mincing no words, she accused BRICS of turning into a Free Market Ploy, 
that serves the interest of big capital. BRICS is no more interested in 
the annihilation of caste or in the welfare of its people, she said. The 
question of gender equality and justice is not a priority for BRICS 
anymore. Even if the governments of BRICS nations have started co-opting 
the language of the civil society and social movements during Summits 
like these, they end up as just words and are never implemented once the 
summit is over. It is fast turning into an institution that serves the 
interests of the elites in developing countries.

Most of the speakers, who spoke at the event emphasised on the need to 
build solidarities of communities in the BRICS countries and the need 
for the civil society in these countries to set a people’s agenda that 
can overcome the consumerist and destructive agendas of capital.

Maria Luisa Belo, representing the feminist movement in Brazil, spoke 
about the threat that democracies across the world are facing today. She 
also commented on the overturn of democracy and the coup orchestrated by 
the country’s elites and imperialists countries. The new government that 
came through the coup has already taken anti-people measures, she said. 
Maria, in her speech, read out the demand of the feminist movements in 
Brazil that is calling upon the world’s institutions, including BRICS, 
to come up with a people’s agenda to defeat patriarchy and poverty. She 
emphasised on the need to build an alliance of social movements in all 
these countries to make this a possibility.

Trevor Ngwane, who led several workers’ struggles in South Africa and 
also an academic, recounted the extreme levels of inequality that exists 
in the South African Society. He called for a pan -African unity and 
expressed his doubts over South Africa representing the voice of Africa 
all by itself.

Dorothy Guerrero, while commenting on China spoke about the urban-rural 
divide that exists in the country. She rued the steps taken by the 
Chinese authorities in curtailing migration from the rural to urban, 
while doing little to improve the country side. She spoke about the 
increasing corporate control over people’s resources – leading to 
massive protests by people in the countryside, led mostly by the 
peasants. Yet, the news of such resistances rarely make it to the global 

Several people’s representatives from Goa also made presentations at the 
end of the plenary, which included, Sabina Martis, Caroline Collaso, Fr. 
Maverick, Favita Dias and Thalmann Pereira. Most of them spoke about the 
massive loot of natural resources that is taking place in Goa. They also 
spoke about the negative impact of corporate led tourism on small 
businesses in Goa and the ecological damages being inflicted. The 
speakers also pointed out at the atrocities being committed on women, 
Dalits and Adivasis in the state, while attempting to appropriate resources.

Soon after the opening plenary, the assembly held several simultaneous 
workshops that addressed issues of Food Sovereignty Nutritional and 
Agrarian Crisis, The Nuclear Power Push in BRICS countries, 
Parliamentary Oversight on New Development Bank and IFIs, Palestine: 
Building solidarities in BRICS, BRICS banks – and what does it mean to 
people, Energy Democracy and Labour Perspectives, Corporate Loot of 
Natural Resources and Alternatives from BRICS countries.

More information about the Marxism mailing list