[Marxism] In San Francisco, Making a Living From Your Billionaire Neighbor’s Trash

Louis Proyect lnp3 at panix.com
Sun Apr 7 14:22:54 MDT 2019

NY Times, April 7, 2019
In San Francisco, Making a Living From Your Billionaire Neighbor’s Trash
By Thomas Fuller

SAN FRANCISCO — Three blocks from Mark Zuckerberg’s $10 million Tudor 
home in San Francisco, Jake Orta lives in a small, single-window studio 
apartment filled with trash.

There’s a child’s pink bicycle helmet that Mr. Orta dug out from the 
garbage bin across the street from Mr. Zuckerberg’s house. And a vacuum 
cleaner, a hair dryer, a coffee machine — all in working condition — and 
a pile of clothes that he carried home in a Whole Foods paper bag 
retrieved from Mr. Zuckerberg’s bin.

A military veteran who fell into homelessness and now lives in 
government subsidized housing, Mr. Orta is a full-time trash picker, 
part of an underground economy in San Francisco of people who work the 
sidewalks in front of multimillion-dollar homes, rummaging for things 
they can sell.

Trash picking is a profession more often associated with shantytowns and 
favelas than a city at the doorstep of Silicon Valley. The Global 
Alliance of Waste Pickers, a nonprofit research and advocacy 
organization, counts more than 400 trash picking organizations across 
the globe, almost all of them in Latin America, Africa and southern Asia.

But trash scavengers exist in many United States cities and, like the 
rampant homelessness in San Francisco, are a signpost of the extremes of 
American capitalism. A snapshot from 2019: One of the world’s richest 
men and a trash picker, living a few minutes’ walk from each other.

Mr. Orta, 56, sees himself as more of a treasure hunter.

“It just amazes me what people throw away,” he said one night, as he 
found a pair of gently used designer jeans, a new black cotton jacket, 
gray Nike running sneakers and a bicycle pump. “You never know what you 
will find.”

Mr. Orta says his goal is to earn around $30 to $40 a day from his 
discoveries, a survival income of around $300 a week.

Trash picking is illegal in California — once a bin is rolled out onto 
the sidewalk the contents are considered the possession of the trash 
collection company, according to Robert Reed, a spokesman for Recology, 
the company contracted to collect San Francisco’s garbage. But the law 
is rarely enforced.

Mr. Orta was born in San Antonio, Tex., one of 12 children. He spent 
more than a dozen years in the Air Force, loading aircraft during the 
Persian Gulf war of 1991 and was dispatched to Germany, Korea and Saudi 
Arabia. By the time he returned to the United States, his wife had left 
him, and he struggled with alcoholism and homelessness. He moved to San 
Francisco, and five years ago qualified for a program assisting 
chronically homeless veterans.

At dusk he leaves his apartment building, which is wedged between a 
popular brunch spot for tech workers and a cannabis shop in the heart of 
the Mission neighborhood. The smell of marijuana fills the vestibule. 
Walking up a steep hill lined with mature trees, he passes homes that 
could pass for works of art: Victorians, some with stained glass and 
elaborate cornices and moldings painted in a soft palette of pastels, 
ocher, celadon and teal. A virtual tour of the neighborhood on the 
Zillow site shows that homes valued at $3 million and above are the norm.

But Mr. Orta doesn’t look at the architecture. He walks the streets, 
slightly stooped, his eyes peeled on the ground and a flashlight in his 
back pocket. His friends call him the Finder.

On the six times Mr. Orta went out with a reporter, he followed a 
variety of circuits, but usually ended up exploring his favorite alleys 
and a dumpster that has been bountiful. (The first rule of dumpster 
scavenging, he said, is to make sure there’s no raccoon or possum in 
there.) In March, the dumpster yielded a box of silver goblets, dishes 
and plates, as if someone had yanked a tablecloth from underneath a 
feast in some European chateau.

“How do you say it?” William Washington, one of Mr. Orta’s trash-picking 
colleagues, remarked one night. “One man’s trash is another man’s treasure.”

Mr. Orta’s other recent discoveries: phones, iPads, three wristwatches 
and bags of marijuana. (“I smoked it,” he said when asked how much he 
got for the pot.) In late August or September, as participants return 
from the annual Burning Man festival in the Nevada desert, Mr. Orta says 
he often finds abandoned bicycles covered in fine sand.

Sign Up for the Crossing the Border Newsletter
The U.S.-Mexico border is a daily headline. A political football. And 
also home to millions of people. Every week for the next few months, 
we'll bring you their stories, far from the tug-of-war of Washington 

Mr. Orta says he only takes what people have clearly thrown away, 
although 14 years ago he spent a few months in jail for breaking into 
someone’s garage in Sacramento and trying to steal a wrench for his 
bicycle. “It was a dumb mistake,” he said.

For years San Francisco has been a global beacon of recycling, 
attracting a stream of government ministers, journalists and students 
from across the globe to study the sorting facilities of Recology.

But the city is also full of young, affluent people preoccupied with 
demanding jobs and long commutes for whom the garbage can is a tempting 
way to get rid of that extra pair of jeans or old electronics cluttering 
their closet.

“We have a lot of trash of convenience,” said Mr. Reed, the spokesman 
for Recology. “You’ve got more and more tech people here and this city 
is moving faster and faster. These people have short attention spans. 
Some discard items that ought to be repurposed through a thrift shop.”

Trash pickers fall into several broad categories. For decades, elderly 
women and men have collected cardboard, paper, cans or bottles, lugging 
impossibly large bags around the city and bringing them to recycling 
centers for cash.

The city is most concerned about the battered pickup trucks, known as 
mosquito fleets, that buzz around San Francisco collecting recyclables 
on an industrial scale, depriving Recology, and ultimately the city, of 
income, said Bill Barnes, a spokesman for the city administrator’s office.

“That’s a significant challenge for residents because it results in 
higher garbage rates,” Mr. Barnes said.

Trash pickers like Mr. Orta are in yet another category, targeting items 
in the black landfill garbage bins whose contents would otherwise go to 
what’s known as the pit — a hole in the ground on the outskirts of the 
city that resembles a giant swimming pool, where nonrecyclable trash is 
crushed and compacted by a huge bulldozer and then carried by a fleet of 
trucks to a dump an hour and a half away. The city exports about 50 
large truckloads a day.

Nick Marzano, an Australian photographer who publishes a glossy 
magazine, Mission Gold, which documents the world of trash pickers in 
San Francisco, estimates there are several hundred garbage scavengers in 
the city.

“It’s a civic service as I see it,” Mr. Marzano said. “Rather than this 
stuff going to landfill the items are being reused.”

Mr. Marzano says there is overlap among trash picking and homelessness 
and public drug use — the street conditions that have ranked at the top 
of residents’ concerns for several years. But he sees trash picking, and 
the spontaneous sidewalk markets that pop up in neighborhoods like the 
Mission and Tenderloin, as a form of entrepreneurship.

“It’s the primary form of income for people who have no other income,” 
he said.

Mr. Orta sells what he retrieves at impromptu markets on Mission Street 
or at a more formal market on Saturdays on Julian Avenue. Children’s 
toys very rarely sell — parents don’t like the idea that they have come 
from the trash. Women’s clothing is iffy. But men don’t seem to care as 
much where the clothing came from, and jeans are easy to hawk for $5 or 
$10 a pair.

Mr. Orta’s favorite item retrieved from the trash is one that he will 
not sell: a collection of newspapers from around the world documenting 
the course of World War II. He wonders why anyone would have thrown that 

On a recent Tuesday evening — the eve of trash collection in Mr. 
Zuckerberg’s neighborhood — Mr. Orta didn’t find anything worth keeping 
in the Facebook founder’s two garbage cans. Mr. Zuckerberg has at least 
one other home in the San Francisco Bay Area; this one he bought in 
November 2012 for $9,999,000 through a company he controls.

In the blue recycling bin marked with Mr. Zuckerberg’s address, there 
were A&W diet root beer cans, cardboard boxes and a junk mail credit 
card offer. In the black landfill bin were remnants of a chicken dinner, 
a stale baguette and Chinese takeout containers.

Mr. Orta pulled apart a garbage bag in the black bin.

“Just junk — nothing in there.”

Susan Beachy and Alain Delaquérière contributed research.

More information about the Marxism mailing list