[Marxism] In Syria, Health Workers Risk Becoming ‘Enemies of the State’
lnp3 at panix.com
Wed Dec 4 09:14:48 MST 2019
NY Times, Dec. 4, 2019
In Syria, Health Workers Risk Becoming ‘Enemies of the State’
By Rick Gladstone and Malachy Browne
The nearly 9-year-old conflict in Syria has been punctuated by repeated
violations of what is considered acceptable in war, including the
military’s use of chemical weapons, torture of prisoners and recurrent
bombings of hospitals in rebel-held areas. Less attention has been paid
to another outcome: the government’s criminalization of medical care.
On Wednesday, Physicians for Human Rights, a group that has documented
the collapse of Syria’s health care system, released a study asserting
that over the course of the war, President Bashar al-Assad has
successfully made medical assistance to his enemies a crime.
Whether it is disinfecting a fighter’s wound or even supplying
painkillers to clinics in an insurgent-held neighborhood, such acts are
punishable under a counterterrorism law enacted by Mr. Assad’s
government just over a year after the conflict began in March of 2011. A
special court has tried tens of thousands under the law, including many
“This report illustrates how the Syrian government has effectively
criminalized the provision of nondiscriminatory care to all, regardless
of political affiliation,” Physicians for Human Rights said in the
study. Health workers who provide care in line with their legal and
ethical obligations, it said, are branded as “enemies of the state” in
The study is based on extensive interviews with 21 formerly detained
Syrian health care workers who have fled the country, including seven
physicians, four pharmacists, three medical volunteers, one paramedic
and one psychiatrist. All said they had endured torture and
interrogations while imprisoned and did not want to be identified by
name, fearing retribution against their families or against themselves
if they ever returned.
A majority of them were arrested, the study said, “because of their
status as care providers, and their real or perceived involvement in the
provision of health services to opposition members and sympathizers.”
The New York Times interviewed three of them who said they had been
detained and interrogated for months. They described cells so cramped
that inmates took turns to rest. Two of them — a pharmacist and a
surgeon — said they had been arrested at their workplaces.
Most of the former detainees described a similar process of extracting
confessions that could be prosecuted under the counterterrorism law, the
Physicians for Human Rights study said. “Most had judicial review of
their cases by either military field courts, military courts, or
counterterrorism court, where due process protections are suspended in
practice,” it said.
There was no immediate comment by the Syrian authorities to the study.
Mr. Assad’s government has repeatedly defended the counterterrorism law
as a necessity for what he contends is his success in retaking and
stabilizing most of the country, where by some estimates a half-million
people have been killed and roughly half the prewar population of 22
million have fled their homes.
Ibrahim al-Kasem, a Syrian lawyer who used to represent detainees, said
that trials in military courts are held in secret, and detainees can be
tried in the counterterrorism court without their lawyers. In such
settings, he said, “the judges have the ability to do anything.”
Mr. al-Kasem is now the executive director of the Caesar-File Group,
established after a Syrian military police photographer code-named
“Caesar” released 55,000 images in 2014 believed to show evidence of the
systematic torture and death of thousands of detainees.
Rights activists and legal scholars say the counterterrorism law itself
is exceedingly vague on what constitutes terrorism so that even peaceful
acts could be prosecuted. They say the law also violates a precept of
the Geneva Conventions that obliges doctors and other health care
professionals to treat the wounded and sick, regardless which side they
“The law is problematic,” said Mai El-Sadany, legal and judicial
director at the Tahrir Institute for Middle East Policy, a
Washington-based research group. “The reality is that under this law,
anyone could be a terrorist.”
When and if the Syria war ends, she said, keeping such a law on the
books would present an enormous challenge to rebuilding the country.
“How can people begin to return to a state where they suffer the risk of
prosecution?” she said.
Mr. Assad’s government was a pioneer in the targeting of health care
workers as a battlefield strategy, and has been ignoring criticism of
the policy for years. The United Nations Commission of Inquiry, a panel
of investigators that has been collecting evidence of human rights
violations in Syria, said back in 2013 that government forces had been
systematically denying treatment to the sick and wounded in areas
controlled by the opposition.
“The denial of medical care as a weapon of war is a distinct and
chilling reality of the war in Syria,” the panel said.
Michiel Hofman, the senior humanitarian specialist at Doctors Without
Borders, a medical charity that operates in insurgent-held areas of
northern Syria, traced the targeting of health care workers to the
prelude to the war, when peaceful protesters wounded by Mr. Assad’s
security forces sought treatment at hospitals.
“The authorities said, yes you can treat people but you have to report
the patients to the police. Patients didn’t want to be reported to the
police, so health care workers created clinics in homes and underground
hospitals,” Mr. Hofman said. “The Syrian authorities regarded these
hospitals as illegal, right from the start, and a vicious cycle was
created early in the conflict.”
Asked about the prospects for rebuilding Syria’s health care system, Mr.
Hofman was pessimistic.
“The reason for the persecution of medical workers has not been
removed,” he said. “Attacks on health care have become the new normal.”
The vast majority of detainees interviewed by Physicians for Human
Rights said they would not go back to Syria under the current
conditions, said Rayan Koteiche, one of the study’s authors. “The
continuing threat and persecution of professions including medical
professionals is a huge barrier to returning,” he said. “To freely
practice in accordance with their code of ethics — they don’t see that
Carlotta Gall, Jack Ewing and Karam Shoumali contributed reporting.
More information about the Marxism